Because the food is better (although pricier too)than average bar food, my friends and I have given Gaslight three tries over the last couple of months. But service is slow - with about 7 people in the place last night, the bartender took 20 minutes to make up 2 martinis (but had plenty of time to watch the tvs). And it took an hour for our burgers to show up. Bad service leaves a bad taste and we won't go back any time soon.
Pros: Good food, Good atmosphere
Cons: Slow bartenders, Slow kitchen