JavaScript is not enabled.
Fat Sal's Pizza - 5 Reviews - 510 9TH Ave, New York, NY - Direct Selling Businesses Reviews - Phone (212) 594-9462

Fat Sal's Pizza

510 9TH Ave
New York, NY 10018
(212) 594-9462
Incorrect info? Correct your listing


( 3 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 2 )


Outrageously delicious!!!!!


This is the ABSOLUTE worst food experience I have had in NYC. I ordered from this place because it was in my local list on the Seamlessweb directory. Well, when the delivery gu...

Editorial review from GrubHub 3/21/2014

Outrageously delicious!!!!! more

Editorial review from GrubHub 11/15/2013

my food was not delivered more

Editorial review from GrubHub 3/4/2013

amazing penne alla vodka with grilled chicken! more

Absolute Worst Food / Delivery experience I have had in my LIFE! 6/13/2007

This is the ABSOLUTE worst food experience I have had in NYC. I ordered from this place because it was in my local list on the Seamlessweb directory. Well, when the delivery guy arrived an hour later, he rang my bell like a mad man, I kept buzzing the door to let him in. He kept buzzing and buzzing. Finally 5 mins later, he comes out of the elevator and comes to me and says: "" No one likes coming 10 blocks to deliver your food."" I could smell the booze on his breath and this was at lunch time! So, I felt sorry for him and gave him an extra $2 on top of the credit card tip, and said sorry. **WELL GET THIS.. So I open my food and it all has been smashed in, Salad dressing everywhere, my food in the bag. I can't believe this has happened and cannot eat it now because who knows what else was in it. I called the restaurant and guess what, no one seems to speak English and the manager is not there. Do not Order here. If you are the owner, contact me ASAP: Cons: Delivery Guys Wreck Your Food If They Have To Travel 10 Blocks more


I have been in NYC for 9 years now- eaten at dozens of pizza places- THIS WAS THE WORST> after i received my pizza without plates/ napkins or even a pen to sign my credit card slip with. I said thank you and went into my apt. like everyone does. I opened the lid- ALL of the toppings have moved to one side of the box- and the dough was soggy. I ran out to catch the delivery boy- brought him back in showed him the pizza and he said "" SO what...Call them"" so i did, and the delivery boy told him that it was nothing really- that only one slice was messed up. It was the WHOLE PIZZA- and nothing was done- DO NOT ORDER FROM FAT SALS- unless you want a pile of cheese on the side of the box with some soggy dough. DISGUSTING Pros: fast delivery- but undercooked- you decide which is better! Cons: read review- ALL more

No frills, but great food 11/9/2002

Don't expect Italian dining when you come to Fat Sal's. You can sit down and watch TV with the cooks, or do like I do, and take it home to eat. The pizza is simple and tasty. But, my recommendation is the clam sause pasta. It is absolutely delicious, and affordable. By the way, the cooks and delivery boys are actually quite friendly, if you do decide to eat in! Pros: great food, affordable, friendly staff Cons: no fancy dining more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Fat Sal's Pizza

20% OFF all yearly plans
Use spring at checkout. Expires 6/30/2018

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Monday 11:00 AM - 10:30 PM Tuesday 11:00 AM - 10:30 PM Wednesday 11:00 AM - 10:30 PM Thursday 11:00 AM - 10:30 PM Friday 11:00 AM - 11:45 PM Saturday 11:00 AM - 11:45 PM Sunday 11:00 AM - 10:30 PM
  • Payments:

    Discover, Master Card, Visa, American Express
  • Neighborhoods:

    Midtown, Garment District