Apparently Brooklyn is a 'high theft' area, which although we were not actually driving the car in Brooklyn, was an issue. As Brooklyn registered drivers, were charged an extra $110, when we went to pick up the car. Somehow we should have known this according to them, although our reservation was quoted without this fee. Plus they didn't have the mid size car we reserved (as we were three people traveling), and had to take a compact car, with no reimbursement. And all of this came with an extra helping of attitude as well.
Pros: the car was clean
Cons: didn't have the car we reserved, charged us an extra $110 - Brooklyn 'tax,' tank of gas not full