Unfortunately, Dewey's is one of those establishments that spends more time on the building than on the food that will be served. It's nice-looking, but the pizza isn't any better than you can get cheaper at chain restaurants. Their seasonal special looked disgusting, some sort of cheeseburger pizza with a ketchup/mustard sauce if I recall correctly. We weren't impressed.
Pros: Nice new establishment; decent beer on tap, good service
Cons: Pizza is not that great.