In our ten or so visits here: the fish has consistently been fresh, and the menu has been innovative. The people are friendly and even entertaining. We regret to report that the restaurant has become quite popular and reservations are now encouraged (the management undoubtedly sees it differently). Some weekend nights are absolutely riotous - with a packed house and amusing entertainment. But the food and atmosphere have not suffered.
Pros: Fresh fish, Innovation encouraged, Relaxed, interactive
Cons: Getting crowded