JavaScript is not enabled.
Cooke's Corner - 6 Reviews - 618 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY - Restaurants Reviews - Phone (212) 712-2872

Cooke's Corner

Claim
marker
618 Amsterdam Ave
New York, NY 10024
marker
(212) 712-2872
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Main categories:

Restaurants

Related categories:

Food & Dining

Reviews

( 2 )
( 3 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 1 )

Best

Great find on UWS. We had a work holiday party at Cooke's, with wine education. It was the best holiday party I've ever been to. The food was superb, the atmosphere enchanting, th...

Worst

Ms

My husband and I were big fans of the restaurant when it first opened. On our past two visits, we have watched the service decline (no one checks to see how your meal is going, n...

Consistently Good 1/6/2005

Delicious, thoughtfully prepared food from a well chosen, small menu. I always have a good meal there. The wait staff is efficient and attentive. And the wine list is pretty good, although they used to have more Italian wines (which Im partial to). Its worth the trip for a casual, but sorta upscale, evening. Good prix-fixe, too. Pros: food, ambiance, service more

Cooke's is great!!! 10/9/2004

Great find on UWS. We had a work holiday party at Cooke's, with wine education. It was the best holiday party I've ever been to. The food was superb, the atmosphere enchanting, the service was impeccable. The owners are awesome! We loved it so much that we had our wedding dinner there. A day filled of wonderful memories, our guest raved about the venue, service and food. Just wish there was a Cooke's cookbook. Highly recommend. Pros: Food is delicious, atmosphere, Reasonalbe price more

Ms 2/28/2004

My husband and I were big fans of the restaurant when it first opened. On our past two visits, we have watched the service decline (no one checks to see how your meal is going, no one person serves you twice), the quality of the food decline and the ambience decline (the tables are tightly packed in and it is rushed, hurried service). When I tried to speak with the owner, she could not have cared less about what I had to say. I would never recommend this place. more

Nice Surprise!!! 1/28/2004

My wife and I walked-in one Friday night because we had always been intrigued when walking by this place. We were not looking for a romantic meal, but it became one. The restaurant is small, quaint, and quiet. It is very condusive to enjoyable conversation. The food was a nice surprise. My wife order the pre-fix ($18) with an entree of beef medallions (3 large, very tender, and juicy medallions...even though my wife ordered it medium well). I ordered a filet off the menu. It was also very good and cooked perfectly medium-rare. Being originally from NE, I am often disappointed with steak in NY. But I was impressed C'sC had such flavorful selections. Service was pleasant, helpful, and in no way pushy. The whole dining experience was simply relaxing. It would be a good first date because it is quiet and doesn't appear to be a romantic. Pros: good food, reasonably priced, quiet by NY standards more

Great UWS choice 10/10/2003

Cooke's Corner isn't well known, but the food is delicious. They offer a great prix fixe meal - delicious choices for $18 (three courses). Even if you go with the regular money, it's a real deal for wonderful food. Always fresh, not too crowded (though the room is small). Great fish and meat selections. The wine list is impressive and reasonably-priced. If you're looking for a UWS dinner spot for a date or with friends, hurry! Service is professional and efficient, without being rushed. Pros: food, wine list, service Cons: small space more

Competent Cooking at Cooke's 10/3/2003

Given the fact that it is populated by foodies, it's surprising that there aren't more places on the Upper W. Side that offer what Cooke's does now: meals that are satisfying, generous, innovative, competently executed and presented, and relatively inexpensive. The Prix Fixe menu offers choices from about five appetizers (mostly generous salads), five entrees (beef, fish or organic chicken, perfectly prepared)and five desserts (including a german chocolate cake: a huge cylinder with fresh schlag, enough for two), all for about $18. Pros: Fine value, Variety, Friendly service Cons: Not large more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Cooke's Corner




SPRING SALE!!!:
20% OFF all yearly plans
Use spring at checkout. Expires 6/30/2018

Additional information

  • Neighborhoods:

    Midtown, Upper West Side
badge