Location is key for the Colonial - located only one block from the water and smack dab in the middle of Edgartown, this inn provides great views. The rooms are rather small - so I would suggest getting a room with a balcony - service was very friendly - but organization at the front desk was little under par. Don't worry - on MV people don't lock their doors, bikes and they leave their keys in the ignition. Oh ask for more blankets - you get plenty of pillow (8) but only 1 real blanket.
Pros: Location, Parking, Views
Cons: Food, Amenities