We never miss an opportunity to go to Cellini's when we're in NYC. My wife and I just walked in one day without knowing a thing about the place. We were delighted to find a great restaurant, with excellent food, reasonable prices, and very good service. It seemed as though most of the people there were regulars or people like us who just stopped in and decided to try it. You don't go to Cellini's if you are on your first date. It doesn't have the ambiance for that. But if you are now at a stage in your relationship where you just want a great meal in a friendly restaurant then Cellini's is the place for you. We've been there many times as a couple and recently with a large group and the dining experience was the same - excellent.
Pros: Great food, Excellent Service, Reasonable prices
Cons: Not for romance, Not for kids