JavaScript is not enabled.
Caterina's Restaurant - 10 Reviews - 316 E 53rd St, New York, NY 10022, New York, NY - Restaurants Reviews - Phone (212) 355-5360

Caterina's Restaurant

Claim
marker
316 E 53rd St, New York, NY 10022
New York, NY 10022
marker
(212) 355-5360
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Main categories:

Restaurants

Related categories:

Food & Dining

Reviews

( 6 )
( 2 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 1 )

Best

This is one of those restaurants that makes a neighborhood feel like home. The hungarian and italian food is always fresh, delicious and reasonably priced. There is entertainment ...

Worst

Being Hungarian myself I know the cusine well. It was such a disappointment to go to the only Hungarian restaurant in the city, and have such a terrible experience. I took my in-l...

We had the pleasure of staying at the restaurant 4/19/2009

We had the pleasure of staying at the resturant and I would recommend it to anyone. The staff were so polite and attentive the only word we could use to sum up our experience was WOW. So thank you to all Pros: goulash more

The great "little restaurant around the corner" 1/21/2009

This is one of those restaurants that makes a neighborhood feel like home. The hungarian and italian food is always fresh, delicious and reasonably priced. There is entertainment mon-sat nights and the guests and staff often take the mike. You can eat at the bar or a table. Loyal local crowd. Pros: Good quality and value more

Wonderful Hungarian & Italian cuisine here 10/9/2008

Leba Provided by Partner
We enjoyed our evening at Caterina's so very much. The food was fantastic - the menu is both Hungarian and Italian. The service was outstanding. ... more

Best Cabaret type Restaurant with excellent food in Manhattan!!!! 10/22/2007

Caterina's cannot be beat on any level. The food is spectacular - the ambience is marvelous. There is entertainment nightly and on Friday and Saturday you will find Jerry Scott on the piano and I assure you it will be a night to remember. This is the best place in town for people who enjoy great entertainment in a lovely romantic setting. Your hosts Caterina and Tom will make you feel so at home. Pros: Great Food, great entertainment, great ambience, what else can one ask for???? Party reoom available too Cons: none more

For a fun filled evening go to Caterina's Restaurant. GREAT food, very moderate in price and exceptional entertainment. Join Jerry Scott on Friday and Saturday nights. It;s like New Year's Eve . 10/9/2007

If you want to have a great night out go to Caterina's. Great food, moderate in cost and great entertainment. Jerry Scott is there on Friday and Saturday nights. it''s like New Years Eve every weekend. You won't be disappointed. Pros: Good food, excellent choices and moderate in cost. Excellent location and attentive staff Cons: None more

Jol Ettunk 7/25/2007

Friendly, old school, supper club atmosphere with delicious Hungarian food. Generous serving of schnitzel, nice roast duck--crispy the way it is supposed to be, and savory stuffed cabbage. Very good cucumber salad. A great choice of Hungarian wines. Fun piano bar with patrons and staff singing standards. Wonderful evening out. Pros: Great food, good wine selection, fun piano bar (Thurs & Sat) Cons: None more

A RESTAURANT THAT HAS IT ALL. GREAT FOOD & GREAT ENTERTAINMENT 1/8/2007

If you recall going to restaurants in New York where there was great food and great entertainment in a wonderful romantic setting, then you will love CATERINA'S. They not only have a great menu of both Hungarian and Italian food, they also have marvelous entertainment. Your experience will be a "night to remember". The staff is wonderful and so friendly, Caterina is a marvelous hostess and Tommy, a fabulours host. Your evening will be an experience to remember. This place has it all. Pros: great food, great entertainment in a romantic atmosphere more

Always a delight 4/28/2006

I have been going here for years and have always found everything about this restaurant to be exceptional. Caterina, Tommy and the staff are extremely friendly and most helpful. The food and service have always been superb. It is a very friendly atmosphere and the entertainment on weekends just puts everything over the top. Donald is a bartender, par excellence, Gregory is an outstanding musician and Kelly the maitre de will stun you with his Broadway vocals. In addition to all the above, the guest performers sound as though they just stepped off a stage. The pricing is moderate but a great value for the dollar considering that you are in midtown-Manhattan. This restaurant caters to a mature well dressed clientele and if you are looking for a fun night out, I highly recommend Caterina's. There is a parking garage directly across the street. Pros: Friendly, Atmosphere, Food more

Don't spend your $! 3/28/2006

Being Hungarian myself I know the cusine well. It was such a disappointment to go to the only Hungarian restaurant in the city, and have such a terrible experience. I took my in-laws there who are not Hungarian, and was embarrassed! The food was terrible. It did not have the true Hungarian flavor, it was blan. The appetizer selection was poor, and the main course selection was not that good either. Every single person at my table (it was 6 of us) disliked the food. The only part I liked was the desert and the service was friendly. The prices are way too high for the quality of the food, and the ambiance of the restaurant was shameful. I would not recommend this place and I will not be returning. I'm sticking to mom's cooking! Pros: friendly service, dessert Cons: tasteless food, poor ambiance, too expensive more

Have some songs in mind! 9/7/2003

I was here again on my uncle's birthday bash in August. We dined, drank and were entertained like royalty! Highly recommend for a true Hungarian experience. Make sure to have a few melodies in mind and ask the pianist to play for you. Thank you again Caterina :) Pros: Best for bigger group, Sing along to music, Dance the "csardas" more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Caterina's Restaurant




FALL SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 12/30/2018

Additional information

  • Payments:

    Master Card, American Express, Visa
  • Neighborhoods:

    Midtown East (Turtle Bay), Midtown, Midtown East
badge