JavaScript is not enabled.
Caruso's Italian Restaurant - 1 Reviews - 2956 Willow Street Pike N, Willow Street, PA - Restaurants Reviews - Phone (717) 464-6464

Caruso's Italian Restaurant

2956 Willow Street Pike N
Willow Street, PA 17584
(717) 464-6464
Incorrect info? Correct your listing


( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 1 )


All reviews seem negative


This place has been in Willow Street for a long time. Its very dirty. You can see the ceiling tiles are stained and droopy. The guy behind the counter barely speaks english and...

Editorial review from Citysearch 1/28/2013

DO NOT EAT AT THIS RESTAURANT!!! I know from first hand experiance that this is one of the filthiest establishments in the entire county. I have personally witnessed the cooks serve food outdated by two years. I have also seen them drop food on the dirty floor, and serve it. The dish water is changed very minimally throughout the day, and most times, the dishes are washed in ice cold, greasy water without so much as a sud of soap, using the same sponges for weeks on end, that are falling apart and smell like rotten eggs. The same three towels are used for everything from wiping up messes on the floor, to cleaning tables, to drying dishes. The cooks NEVER wash their hands at all during the course of an antire work day. With the possible exception of when they use the restroom. But even that can't be said for certain, as they are in there unsupervised. In fact - there is no hand soap whatsoever in the entire place, besides what can be found in the customer restroom. Don't believe me? Ask to see the soap they use. They won't be able to provide any. Or, better yet - ask to see the sink they wash their hands in. It is filled like a storage spot, and completely inaccessable. I have watched cooks coughing, sneezing, blowing their noses, eating, rubbing each others sweaty backs, cleaning toilets, taking out garbage - and then, touching customers food, without so much as pretending to even wipe off their hands. They do not use gloves. Or hand sanitizer. They don't even own any. The same goes for hair nets. They don't even attempt to pull back their hair while preparing food. Anyone can look behind the divider and see most of what I'm saying for themself. The level of utter filth and blatant disregard for consumer safety and health that I have seen at this establishment has not only compelled me to speak out against them, but has in turn caused me to be weary of eating out at all. Please trust me when I tell you - DO NOT EAT AT CARUSO'S!!! Or, better yet - don't trust me, and look into these claims for yourself!!! The more people willing to investigate these claims, the more people will contact the health board, and the more likely it will be that places like this are forced to either reform, or go away!\r more

Editorial review from Citysearch 1/28/2013

Amen! SHUT IT DOWN!\r Filthy. Disgustingly so. And shamefully unprofessional. \r I recently placed an order over the phone. Was told to pick it up in 45 minutes. \r When I showed up 45 minutes later, my order was not done. I waited another thirty five minutes until it was ready. \r Lo and behold, when I got home I discovered that it was not my order at all but someone elses. I called about it and was put on hold for 15 minutes before being told to bring back the food I had been given by mistake in exchange for my order. \r I returned with the incorrect order but my order was still not ready. \r After waiting another 25 minutes, I finally got my food. \r I went home and my family and I began eating. And then my son noticed something shiny and sharp sticking out of his slice of pizza. Upon closer inspection, we discovered that it was a fake fingernail!!!!! \r I immediately contacted them by phone and was again put on hold for about 15 minutes and then I was hung up on! \r I returned to the restaurant with the food and asked for a refund. I was treated HORRIBLY. I was called a liar, and a cheat, and asked to leave the premesis! \r I will never go within spitting distance of this place ever again. more

Shut it down 6/27/2010

This place has been in Willow Street for a long time. Its very dirty. You can see the ceiling tiles are stained and droopy. The guy behind the counter barely speaks english and grunts at you. They don't wash their hands. The atmosphere is below average for a pizzaria which is saying something. They have a tv and put on whatever they feel like putting on. They have a stereo and listen to music that isn't really any type of dinner music. Its just gross. Cons: Your likely to become ill more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Caruso's Italian Restaurant

15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 9/30/2018

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon. - Sun. 11am - 10pm
  • Payments:

    American Express, Discover, Visa, Master Card