I really like the selection they have, but it is a selection I can find in many places in the Indianapolis area ($10-$20 cigar selection).
What I did not like is when I walked in, I was NEVER greeted nor was I spoken to until I was buying. The owner was selling to me. I bought a humidor and although I told him this was my first one, he didn't state how to season it or recommend the solutions (although I already knew how).
Furthermore, their house cigars (Maduro's) were $20 (half price since I bought the humidor). They are aweful. They do not burn evenly; they go out within 45 seconds if you do not draw; and it has that ""squishy"" feeling only 25% into it. I did put into humidor on 70/70 and it did not help. Drying out didn't help either, so I am assuming that it was poorly filled. I did smoke four before I gave up and realized that although I only paid .80 each, the cigars from Walgreens is better. I will pay $120 for my Onyx and Romeo Y Julietas before I pay $20 for theirs.
Pros: Great Selection
Cons: Never was greeted or spoke to by owner other than POS.