The first time we went to Capone's Dinner show was at least 7 or 8 years ago. We had the best male server. He was so funny and really made our evening.
The Italian buffet was okay. Obviously bulk cooking but certainly good enough to eat. There was free wine, beer, or soda all evening.
The show was a lot of fun and had audience participation.
The last couple of times we have taken family it hasn't seemed as good to us but the others have enjoyed it. I can only think that the first time you go leaves the best impression.
Capone's is on 192 and you can't miss the sign outside. There is plenty of parking. Don't forget to pick up a coupon in any of the books around and get 50% off. I certainly wouldn't pay full price for it.
We still have the photograph we purchased from them with our 'jail number' on it.