OK, let me get one thing off my chest: Mickey Mantle's did the ultimate betrayal when they briefly renamed the restaurant "Ted Williams" after the Red Sox beat the Yankees in 2004. It was a publicity stunt, and it backfired.
Now, on to the food. The food is so-so at best. The staff is often very friendly, but the prices are a bit high - even for the area - considering what you get. Stick wth the burgers, it's the best value on the menu.
Also, they close too early - the Mick would never turn in at Midnight!!!
In all, this place is NOT a must-visit for Yankee fans.