I really enjoyed eating at Cinelli's on Fayetteville Road recently. We had a large cheese pizza (New York style) and Tiramisu for dessert.
The pizza had a great flavor, and a just-crisp-enough thin crust. It may have been a little greasy, but that's easily overlooked when you are dealing with a pie of this flavor quality.
The tiramisu was also very good. The best I've had around these parts.
I'm very interested in going back to Cinelli's to try some of their pasta dishes, which look amazing. The menu is very extensive.
Pizza prices are reasonable--3 people ate for under $30, including dessert (2 Tiramisus). Pasta prices are higher, but if the dishes are as good as they look, it's worth it.