Carmaya has an innovative menu (Parmasan ice cream for an appetizer?) at VERY reasonable prices. I recommend going on a warm, summer night because the outdoor garden is incredibly romantic -- it even has manicured grass underneath the tables! I loved my entire meal from the creative, summer cocktail to the appetizers to the main course, a wonderful spinach ravioli -- it was truly delicious! One improvement could be made in their service. Although fairly attentive, we couldn't derive a lot of information out of our waiter. Other than that, it was a spectacular meal for 3 people -- with drinks(3), appetizers (2), main courses (3) and desserts (2), it came to about $80 -- not bad for an Italian meal that I thought was in the same ballpark as Lupa.
Pros: Inexpensive, Romantic Garden, Great Food!