I used to live in Baraboo and work on the square. i used to go to this place for lunch all the time. Great tuna steak sandwich, super southwest chicken caesar salad, creative soups and appitizers, YUMMY homemade desserts, awesome homemade salsa and cumin sauce. The staff have been there forever and are really friendly.
Pros: Great food, cozy atmosphere, friendly staff
Cons: i don't live near it anymore :(