I was a die hard Gelesti Celesti fan until I ventured into Carmichael's.....it is by far the best and smoothest ice cream I ever had. I was in a adventurous mode and opted for the cantelope (yes, cantelope) ice cream. I've been hooked ever since. It's a small shop with limited seating but there are tables outside. It's a "word of mouth" joint but I'd rather see it more crowded than gone. So the word is now on the web.
Pros: Quality Ice Cream, Selection, Cute Shop
Cons: Limited Seating