I have only been once, but found no complaints and can't wait to go again. I ordered a veal parm and my fiance ordered the gnocchi. The piece of veal I received was huge, both me and my fiance ate some and I still had leftovers for lunch. The piece was also so tender it just melted in your mouth. The gnocchi was also to die for! I love the sauces they used on both. The appetizer of calamari was clearly very fresh! The atmosphere was exceptionally clean, and I love all of the blue glass decorations. The best part, however, was the staff. The hostess promptly sat us (we had reservations), and waters were always promptly replenished. The best part, though was our waitress. We were celebrating our anniversary and when she found out she came out with a candle on the dessert we ordered for us to celebrate. Little touches are what make a night out worth remembering. We have been so very busy that we had not had time to go out lately, but can't wait to go back and I would recommend to everyone to go to the Blue Grotto.
Pros: amibence, waitstaff, free valet, food, quantity