This is my first review. The Bayberry Cafe was THE place recommended by the locals for the best burger in town. The menu featured burgers, sandwiches and local seafood. My hamburger has just like mom made when I was growing up. A hand-formed patty cooked to order, complimented by a fresh locally baked bun with all the appropriate garnish did not disappoint. My wife sampled the BLT. She was surprised by the amount (lots) of bacon and fresh tomatoes. Very friendly and efficient service in the early afternoon after the lunch rush. If we get back to Islip Town we will definitely be back. Already recommended this place to my son who lives in NYC.
Pros: Fresh ingredients
Cons: Too far from NYC to return before returning home