This place had wonderful pizza, absolutely the best in the neighborhood, and some of the best in the entire city. The decor is great - all Yankees memorabilia. The service is unfortunately lacking. Sometimes I feel like I'm invisible, and they do not have a designated 'order here' sign, which would be a great help. Their 'restaurant' in the back served mostly italian-american fare - too-big portions of alfredo, parms, meatballs, too much sauce, etc - comfort food. The service in the back is always atrocious, but I go here because I'm obviously craving something and 99% of the time its right on. Last time I went I ordered the fetuccini alfredo which is usually really good but it came to me as overcooked egg noodles with butter. Totally disgusting. And the waitress couldn't have cared less - she never offered to bring me another plate, she just took it away and didn't even ask about it, which I thought was unacceptable. But again, its usually great and I won't give up on this place - it will be around for a long long time if the quality is there.
Pros: best neighborhood pizza place
Cons: bad service all around