I love Cosimo's! I go here all the time and have always had awesome food. Pizzas are great, appetizers, specials, salads, and entrees are all fantastic. I've had 90% fantastic experiences but it does get very crowded and loud on the weekends. The only time I got served the wrong meal was on a Saturday night and I think the waitress just couldn't hear what I ordered! Lunch time is a great time to visit. I'm hungry now just thinking about it!!!
PROS: excellent food
CONS: very busy weekend nights