I used to live in Montclair, and Ioved to go to Dobbs on Church St. I loved to clothes selection. But, I also went there because of the customer service. The owner if there, would personally dress me! She would know what would look best and have ideas from her inventory. Their inventory is great--FLAX, Putamayo, White Wash, Willow, etc. Yes, they always took my coffee from me---if I came in wit a cup in my hands--and returned it very nicely when I departed. And the staff was always nice.
Pros: Inventory of nice clothes, jewelry gifts, reasonable prices for what they sold, great seasonal mark-downs
Cons: Parking occasionally difficult