Update 5/8/2012: Over the past year the quality has been consistently excellent, delivery timely and courteous. And my new favorite is the pasta primavera. Along with the accompanying side salad, this is a vegetarian feast, with variety and flavor. End update.
I've had pizza slices, almost every sandwich on the menu, salads and numerous sides over at least 10 orders in the last two months. Consistently good food, timely delivery. I particularly like the baked portabella mushroom.