We went to Kate's on 35th for lunch about a month ago and found the food to be nothing special. The food was merely okay and way overpriced. I do not mind paying extra for organic, fresh foods if prepared well and in interesting ways, but there was nothing special or tasty about the chile relleno (their most popular dish) that I had. It was actually pretty boring (more like a quiche) and hardly had ANY spice to it. The portion size was also very small for a restaurant. I felt full enough, but several others were still hungry after their meals. I won't be going back as I did not feel the money was worth the rather bland food.
Cons: food not worth the money, have to have reservations at least a day in advance