This place is a few blocks from my house and great for last minute rentals because it's open until 1am and movies aren't due until 8pm. I also have Netflix, but this place has a great selection of horror movies, new releases, and movies you didn't even realize you were always looking for. The people who work there are always willing to offer up some ideas of a movie the customer might like and just generally good people. Also check out their collection of great shirts in the window. Into Video is a window I always have to check-out while walking through the neighborhood.
Pros: open late, eclectic selection, late return hours, great merchandise, snacks