My family and I are HUGE fans of Maestro's in Addison. We stopped in one afternoon after a concert at Addison Circle and have been hooked ever since; we make it a point to have our "Family Pizza Night" there every Friday night!
Not only is the location perfect (smack-dab in the middle of Addison) for a quick by-the-slice order or a sit-down meal, but the service is excellent. The owners are there at the restaurant almost every hour of the day and make it a point to stop by and make you feel welcome.
The pizzas (we usually go with old-school pepperoni) come in a variety of sizes and have almost any topping under the sun, as well as a handful of specialty pizzas. Don't make the mistake of thinking this is a straight pizza joint, however. Their lasagna and pastas are some of the best and are made fresh as you order.
A great selection of beer and weekly email coupons for special events/ Cowboys/Stars/Mavs game days make this a tough spot to top if you're looking for the perfect NY style pizzeria.
Pros: The thin crust pizza is to die for, great ingredients
Cons: Not enough seating...get there early!