For Valentine's Day, I took my girlfriend to South Gate and LOVED IT. The dinner was a pre-fix menu, at only $88 per person (that's FANTASTIC for Valentine's Day in New York). First of all, the place has a live jazz band, that places some cool beats in the background.
The place is 100% classy, with a VERY old-world feel to it. I felt like Frank and Dino were going to walk in the door!
The waiter pulls out the table for the lady, so that she can have the nice, plush couch to sit on. The food was really good, and the overall experience was great. Would HIGHLY recommend this place to ANYONE!
After dinner, right outside, there are carriages for a nice, Central Park Horse drawn carriage ride. ENJOY!
Pros: Great food, great prices, great service