I love this place! The staff is incredibly friendly! Because it's privately-owned, they're more willing to bargain with you on prices.
They have a huge supply of vintage clothing and odd knick-knacks. Besides Party City, this is my favorite place for costume wigs. They also rent costumes--all year, not just Halloween. If you're a cosplayer, this is heaven.
I can't recommend this shop enough. My only gripe is its weird hours and poor parking situation. You have to park at the Food Lion across the street, then sprint past traffic. But it's worth it!
PROS: Excellent selection. Awesome staff! Tons of costumes and wigs!
CONS: Poor parking. Weird hours.