I've gone to Dan Hutton's for 5 years and he's simply the best. The people in Mr. Hutton's garage always do great work, Mr. Hutton will not do unnecessary work (and in fact tries to avoid doing things that will increase your bill if they are not necessary or if he can find a lower-price soln to your problem), and Mr. Hutton himself is a very nice personable individual.
The only drawback is that Dan Hutton is perhaps too good : he gets so much business that it typically takes me 3-5 days to get in to have my car looked at (although it never takes more than a day to get the repairs done)
Pros: Professional, honest, craftsman of the highest caliber
Cons: Can take 3-5 days to get your car in