Carmella's is right next to the Hampton Inn in Tiffin. It is part reception hall, part restaurant. The dining area is decorated in a Venetian style and the atmosphere is nice. Decent wine/beer list. The food is surprisingly good, especially their pizzas (chicken alfredo pizza was killer). Desserts are not all homemade but are decent. Good prices too considering it is the only place in walking distance from the hotel. Overall worth checking out in the area.
Pros: Inexpensive, Great Pizza