I've been going to Handel's since before I can remember. I grew up just a few blocks from the original location in Youngstown--and some of my fondest memories of childhood revolve around the walks to and from Handle's. The anticipation on the way there was incredible and the satisfaction on the way home was unmatched. Best bet? Chocolate Pecan--everytime.
Pros: Chocolate pecan, Butter Brickle, Mocha Crunch