I have been to Carrie Cerino's about fifteen times over the past six years, and the food, service, and ambiance is second to none every time. Consistent. Delicious. Just about everything is homemade, and it is worth every penny. Every server has been welcoming, knowledgeable, and timely. When it comes to the food, it is always hard to choose because everything is so tasty. Carrie's is so good that I hope to get married in Cleveland someday for the sole fact that I want my reception there.
Pros: food, service, ambiance, plenty of parking
Cons: a far drive from the Eastside, but absolutely worth it