JavaScript is not enabled.
Brooks & Porter - 5 Reviews - 16 Merrick Ave., Merrick, NY 11566, Merrick, NY - Restaurants Reviews - Phone (516) 379-9400

Brooks & Porter


16 Merrick Ave., Merrick, NY 11566
Merrick, NY 11566

(516) 379-9400
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Main categories:



Steak Houses

Related categories:

Food & Dining

( 0 )
( 0 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 4 )


All reviews seem negative


If I could give less than 1 star I would. My wife and I joined about 30 other people for a planned party....

Never go here 5/9/2012

by all at Menuism Provided by Menuism
If I could give less than 1 star I would. My wife and I joined about 30 other people for a planned party.... more

Never go here 5/9/2012

all Provided by Partner
If I could give less than 1 star I would. My wife and I joined about 30 other people for a planned party. The bill was presented to the table duri... more

Not worth the money for the food 1/2/2012

My boyfriend and I went here on a whim. We've been to several steakhouses on long island and the boroughs. We both were extremely disappointed with this one, we got there at 7 pm for a Monday night dinner and the place was dead...we should've just left when we noticed it was empty. We usually share a porterhouse for two but decided not to for some reason. We asked the waiter if they had 1/2 price bottles of wine and he told us no so we just ordered a glass each (however, on the back of the dessert menu it said that they offer 1/2 price bottles on Sunday-Tuesday). We started off by sharing a wedge salad and he ordered a french onion soup, both were nothing terrific. I ordered a sea scallops and he ordered the skirt steak with two sides. The sea scallops were extremely fishy and his skirt steak was extemely bland so he had to to use steak sauce. Our bill came to $150 with tip for two people and we didn't even have dessert because I felt like it wouldn't have been worth it. We were both extremely disappointed and do not think it's neccessary to return. If you are looking for a steakhouse on the south shore, I'd recommend going to Frank's in RVC for a fair price and the north shore is flooded with them on Northern Blvd. more

bad ownership!! bring back the originals 11/9/2011

Great service from Zdmen, however the owners were very indecent. The constant use of vulgar language to their staff and each other was profound, Not to mention one was completely drunk. I do not recommend this place to anyone. It is over priced and poorly run. If you take the risk of being over charged and bad mouthed, be sure to request Zdmen. He is the only good thing that will come of your experience. And was completely turned away after witnessing an owner curse at a young woman in the dining room who happened to be very sweet, Lisa was her name if I recall. Both servers great food and ownership vulgar! NO guest should witness a staff member being let go, Which my wife and kids did. Lisa was cursed at, embarrassed and fired for the entire dining area to see! I am not in favor by any means of putting money into pockets of those who look down on and treat anyone that way. They lost my business and I hope this saves you from wasting your time and money!! more

Fading star 4/15/2011

When this place first opened a couple of years ago it was first class steakhouse likes of which not seen on the south shore of long island. On a recent visit, there is a air of desperation. They have discontinued their fabulous sushi bar, one of things that made b&p special. They had a god awful singer on a keyboard playing to the bar crowd who was loud and off key. It was a conversation killer at our table. Granted, the steaks are still first rate, but they are losing that elegance and sophistication that they started with. For a Friday night, they were half empty and yet the service was exceptionally slow. For this kind of $$$$', I expect more than a singles scene karaoke bar! B&p must regroup and get their act together, if they want to stay relevant because there are so many better choices on the north shore. more
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for Brooks & Porter

15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 10/1/2019
Additional information
  • Neighborhoods: Medford, Long Island