This was the first place I checked out when I moved into NYC a few years ago (just around the block) and I was immediately impressed with their wings and quesadillas. A notch above the rest, they serve great (and huge!) quesadillas and some of the best buffalo wings (with a huge sauce/heat selection) that I've had in the city. Of course that's because there's an Atomic Wings in the place, but it really helps sets the bar apart from others. If I'm not in the mood for wings, I'll opt for the chicken tenders soaked in buffalo sauce which is just as tasty.
The only downside is that there usually aren't a lot of people in there (the exception being after a Zog sporting event). But at the same time that can be a nice change of pace, particularly if you're looking for a low key night to catch up with friends. I think it's an underrated little neighborhood bar that's worth a try.
Pros: Atomic Wings, pool table, quesadillas
Cons: Nachos, it's often a little dead