JavaScript is not enabled.
Blue Moon Pizza - 72 Reviews - 2359 Windy Hill Rd Se Ste 100, Marietta, GA - Pizza Restaurants Reviews - Phone (770) 984-2444
top 10

Blue Moon Pizza

Claim
marker
2359 Windy Hill Rd Se Ste 100 (at Cobb Parkway SE)
Marietta, GA 30067
marker
(770) 984-2444
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Photos

Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA
Blue Moon Pizza - Marietta, GA

Reviews

( 58 )
( 5 )
( 3 )
( 2 )
( 4 )

Best

I came in from out of town and a local friend brought me here... The worst part about it was that is was on the last day of my trip - had it been the first I would have been there...

Worst

My friends and I regularly gather at the Windy Hill Blue Moon to enjoy pizza, trivia, and a good time. We will do this for the last time. Twice in a short period, Blue Moon has ...

Cheese sticks are amazing! 5/16/2012

They have the best mozarella cheese sticks in this world. They are pricey, but worth every penny! Great restaurant! more

Will NOT be back!! 11/11/2011

I just recently ate at the blue moon off of windy hill. I used to be a regular customer until i transfered with my job. After coming back to eat there, I was amazed! The place has changed for the worse. Not only was my server rude and acted like i was bothering him, but the food took forever to get to us. And they didnt look very busy at all! And when it did finally arrive it was wrong!! I have to say also that the place has become ""ghetto""!! I almost felt like i was at the nasty sportsbar next to them(not good). I am very disappointed because the place was good at one point. Maybe ill go try the one at west village and hope for the best. Oh, the food is good but just overpriced. more

Absolutely Amazing!! 9/5/2011

I came in from out of town and a local friend brought me here... The worst part about it was that is was on the last day of my trip - had it been the first I would have been there daily. The waitstaff was extremely friendly despite my group being Boise State fans in 'hostile territory' they were very courteous, respectful, and all around fun. Avery, the kitchen/catering manager, visited with us a couple of times discussing the football game and Blue Moon's plan for expansion. It is, in my opinion, very rare to find a restaurant that not only makes amazing food but also has a genuine desire to make you welcome and taken care of. I will definitely be back on my next visit to the Atlanta area and would recommend this place to EVERYONE. My recommendation is the BBQ chicken pizza with cyan candied bacon.... more

Love it! 4/18/2011

Love the atmosphere! Friendly wait staff! Fast and the food is YUMMY! more

Blue Moon Pizza 9/5/2010

Wow What to say.....over priced food!!!!!! They use glass cleaner to and a dry cloth to clean the tables....so when you sit down your table is covered with lent. The ice scoop is left in the ice bin where all the staff will put their hands while getting your ice (after they handle money)Gross, rubber glove are seldom used while preparing your meal. Shall I go on.......... The only reason I rated them is because I had to.......Never been to the one at west village but who knows they might be better.... more


great pizzia 4/25/2010

Great pizzia, and great atomosphere i really like it and think everyone should try it out.\r more

Out of this WORLD food and service!! 3/28/2010

My husband and I tried Blue Moon Pizza for the first time after reading an article in the paper. We were skeptical because we knew the area and had passed by the shopping center previously. Let me tell you that this is worth every penny! The pizza at Blue Moon is fantastic!! Let me recommend the Sante Fe Chicken and the White pizza, MMMMM! Their appetizers are great as well. We didn't have to wait long for a table and the atmosphere is friendly and comfortable! If you are looking for great pizza, THIS IS IT! The one thing my husband and I were most pleased with was the service!! We are frequent Vinings patrons and we were so happy to have our old favorite bartender as our server. She greeted us with the friendliest smile and very energetic but professional attitude. She looked extremely busy but still greeted us promptly and made sure we felt like we were the most important customers in the room. She recommended not only her personal menu favorites but also the most popular items of the night. Then our food came out quickly, our drinks were never empty and we never had a dirty plate in front of us. Our server at Blue Moon Pizza was the reason we became regular bar customers at her previous job and we will definitely going back now! Don't hesitate to try this restaurant and make sure you ask for Mela, she will make the experience worth it! Pros: great pizza, great price, great service! more

Fantastic pizza, best in Atlanta! 3/19/2010

My husband & I are always trying to find another (er, better) pizza place in Atlanta, esp. something more ""New York"" style (he's from the NE). We had heard that Blue Moon Pizza was good, but had not yet tried it. We finally decided to try it this week -- and BOY oh boy, hands-down, this is by far the best, TASTIEST, most authentic tasting pizza in town! Don't be turned off by driving up to a shopping center with lots of other ""ho hum"" places nearby. Let the food INSIDE keep your trip worth going! Try the MARGHERITA (sp?) pizza, OMG -- and the owner ""warned"" us that it was to die for, it's literally THAT good! we ordered a LARGE and literally could NOT stop eating it, was THAT tasty! The salads are also good, also the service. TRY it, you WON'T be disappointed, and, won't be able to return VERY SOON (the way we feel)!. Cheers! Pros: Best pizza in town, SO tasty! Cons: Nothing, everything (service included) was great! more

good food, but poor service 2/26/2010

My friends and I regularly gather at the Windy Hill Blue Moon to enjoy pizza, trivia, and a good time. We will do this for the last time. Twice in a short period, Blue Moon has not respected our reservations made in advance, and the management seemed like they could care less. Our table was not ready until a half an hour after the time we had reserved it for. We were left standing although we planned in advance to avoid that mess. What's the point of a reservation if tables are not ready ? Finally, a half hour later, we were directed to a table/card table combo to sit. Staff then had the nerve to ask us to stand while they gathered chairs for the card table- although there were chairs at an adjacent vacant table available for immediate use. We were forbidden to use those and instead left standing until the staff returned. Although our reservation was ignored and we were disrespected, management was unapologetic. \r \r On another occasion our reservation was not recorded at all, and we were left without any seats and forced to go elsewhere. No excuse for that on a Friday night with a large group of friends when a reservation was made. Needless to say, the attitude of this location towards its faithful customers is poor. Maybe thay don't need the business. We are not going back to be ignored and disrespected again. Pros: Good food, trivia hangout (sometimes) Cons: no respect for reservations/return customers more

Best Wedge Salad in Town! 1/18/2010

Wedge of Crisp iceberg topped with crumbled bleu cheese and house made CANDIED BACON! mmmmm... .. its sweet, savory, smokey, bacon-y yummy - oh and the pizza is pretty damn good too! Pros: food is great! - cold beer - great service more

Love the Blue Moon! 10/15/2008

\r This place has phenominal pizza, paninis and salads. The salads come ON TOP of pizza bread, instead of just a plate, which I think is really cool (as well as delicious!) They deliver, have decent specials, and taste SO much better than Dominos or Pappa Johns. If you plan on eating in-house beware it gets super busy around lunchtime, so try and go a little early, or a little late, but I have never been dissappointed with anything I've ever ordered at blue moon. I also love that there is a cool, low-key, GOOD restaurant like this located OTP, so I get to save my gas money, and buy an extra round of beers! Pros: Tastes WAY-good. Cons: a little more expensive than the chains more

Best Pizza in the Atlanta Metro area 8/5/2008

I had a great experience at Blue Moon the waiters were very attentive and personable. The food is delicious. Pros: Ambience, Service, and Food more

Great pizza 6/23/2008

It's obvious that many of the reviews on here were written by the same person - the writing style is the same and the reviewers have written about only one place which is Blue Moon. My point is that the owners don't need to create aliases for several people to say how good Blue Moon is. Let your customers do the talking and I think you'll be happy with the results. Blue Moon has great pizza. I never order delivery from anywhere else. It's some of the best pizza I've had in Atlanta. The delivery service could be a little bit better though. It's a mixed bag as to whether your pizza will be delivered warm. Also, a lot of drivers seem to be unfamiliar with the area for some reason and I've had many call me en route to say that they were lost and need help finding my home (and I live just off of a major road so it's not like I'm in the boonies). Besides that, I love this place. Pros: great pizza Cons: delivery is slow and pizza sometimes arrives cold more

Tasty Tasty Ingredients!!! 6/10/2008

This pizza is as close to New York as you can get in atlanta!!! The taste is sensational and vigirating and I would tell many people about my experience. Pros: The best pizza in atlanta hands down Cons: none at the moment more

Great Pizza and fun times! 6/1/2008

We had a group of about 23 people on a Friday night. We had one waitress and she was excellent! Her name was Cassie I think. We all played trivia and had a great time. At first it was a little hard to hear the trivia announcer because the place was packed but he turned up the mic and it was fine from then on. The pizza was very good also. We will be back! Pros: Great Service and Pizza Cons: None that I can think of more

Best pizza in Marietta 5/13/2008

I really enjoyed the different types of pizza to ordered here. They get your food to you quickly. The was expecially important to me with having limited time for you my hour. Great atmosphere. Want to try something new Check out Blue Moon. Wonderfully delicious!!!!! Pros: Loved everything about this place Cons: Nothing to mention more

Not bad!!! 3/6/2008

The pizza was ok. I do think the staff was alittle up tight. Altogether I would visit again but not in a rush to return. If I were in the area it could potentially be a decent lunch spot or meeting place to chat and enjoy my friends and eat a slice. Pros: once order was placed the wait was short Cons: Seating arrangment was crowded waitor keep bumping my chair as she walked by more

Best Any kind of Pizza 2/6/2008

if you love pizza and you love all kinds of toppings including pineapple, ham, veggies, chicken WHATEVER!!! they have it, not to mention the wings cooked to perfection!!! Pros: Get what you pay for Cons: Next to a busy sportsline more

original taste to pizza - great! 1/3/2008

Get the caramelized onions on your pizza. Garlic rolls are also always fresh and tasty. Fun atmosphere. Plenty of parking. Avoid trivia nights if you don't want to play, you won't be able to hear the other people at your table. On the pricier side as for as pizza goes - but worth it! Pros: garlic rolls, pizza, style of place Cons: too loud more
< Previous 1 2 3 4 Next >

Menu for Blue Moon Pizza




SUMMER SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 9/30/2018

Editorial

  • The Scene
    Blue is the color of delicious in this North Metro pizza palace that draws a mix of couples, families, business cohorts and solo diners. The open dining room features a wash of...

  • 5/4/2005 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Monday - Saturday: Open 11 a.m. To 11 p.m.
  • Payments:

    American Express, Discover, Master Card, Visa
badge