JavaScript is not enabled.
Bexley Pizza Plus - 13 Reviews - 2540 E Main St, Columbus, OH - Pizza Restaurants Reviews - Phone (614) 237-3305

Bexley Pizza Plus

Claim
marker
2540 E Main St
Columbus, OH 43209
marker
(614) 237-3305
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Reviews

( 7 )
( 2 )
( 1 )
( 2 )
( 1 )

Best

You've gotta check out the ""new plus"". Same great zas, new location with dine-In, beer and wine. Ordered two pizzas --- Chicken Florentine & Primavera Plus---outstanding crust,...

Worst

I don't get the hype for this pizza. it's overpriced and tastes nothing special at all. If in Bexley, go for Anthony's or Rubinos instead. Cons: nothing special, expensive

All hype 9/26/2009

I was surprised at the poor service and over priced pizza which was not that good at all. Too doughy, under cooked. I had to bring it home and finish baking it. Pros: easy access Cons: poor customer service, over priced, pizza blah more

not a fan 4/21/2009

I don't get the hype for this pizza. it's overpriced and tastes nothing special at all. If in Bexley, go for Anthony's or Rubinos instead. Cons: nothing special, expensive more

The New Plus Rocks! 7/10/2007

You've gotta check out the ""new plus"". Same great zas, new location with dine-In, beer and wine. Ordered two pizzas --- Chicken Florentine & Primavera Plus---outstanding crust, fresh veggies and great service! Pros: fresh dough, baked in deck ovens Cons: expensive--but worth it! more

sad about columbus pizza 6/14/2004

I tried Bexley Pizza Plus for the 1st time yesterday and was very disappointed, especially after reading all the good reviews. The crust was described as thick, chewy, and homeade, but what i had was thin, flavorless, and clearly NOT homeade. It tasted like any other frozen pizza crust you get everywhere else in this city devoid of anything even beginning to resemble good pizza. I also think it is way too expensive for what it is. I would not recommend. more

Best Vegetarian Pizza 12/11/2003

BPP has the BEST veggie pizza in Columbus - The Farmer's Market. A combination of spinach, broccoli, roma tomatoes and feta cheese with the red sauce is PERFECT! Even meat eaters will love it! more

Excellent 11/27/2002

Bexley Pizza Plus has excellent pizza, great service, is fast, efficient, and has good prices. The only downfall of this pizza place is that it is not a restaraunt, and does not deliver. However, Pizza Plus is very much recommended to anyone in the Columbus area, and extremely recommended to anyone near Bexley. more

Simply The Best! 8/28/2002

Always great, dependable and just the way you want it done. more

awesome 8/25/2002

Great pizza!! I had it years ago,, then they opened up a location in Gahanna right around the corner from me. I eat Pizza Plus weekly, and it's always consistent. Two weeks ago I had the Mexican pizza, superb!!!! Keep up the good work guys!!! Pros: consistent, hot, great deal Cons: no wings more

Good... but not the best! 8/15/2002

I have had this pizza, and I really don't see what the rave is. The dough was thick. More like bread. I guess if you like that, then this is your place. I'd rather enjoy the toppings! Cons: Thick, doughy crust more

Needs help 8/14/2002

I drove 12 miles to try this pizza and all i have to say is it is fair to ok. But not the best in columbus. Anmd it is very $$$. You can the same size and cook it your self with all the topping on it at a lot less $. The place could use a make over and a good cleaning. The staff nid not even know much about this web site. Pros: size of pies Cons: price, needs a good clean more

Best Pizza in Columbus 8/13/2002

I was introduced to Pizza Plus about 4 months ago and haven't looked back since. I have lived in Columbus my whole life and have enjoyed many pizzas from many shops. Pizza Plus consistenly has more toppings and more choices than any other shop. I for many years had Masseys,Rubinos and Joseppis as my top places in no particular order but Pizza Plus now moves to the top. Want a great pizza ? Look no further. Want something a little different ? Its here ! Now if they'll just come to Hilliard ! Pros: 30 + toppings, consistent taste, good value Cons: only 2 locations, only 2 locations, only 2 locations more

Pizza the way it oughta be! 8/9/2002

Quite simply, the BEST ingredients and best methods make the best pizza! Pizza Plus is hands-down the best, and no others compare. The Ultimate is my fave, but there are no losers on the gourmet menu -- period. Pricey, yes, but the quality and quantity make it well worth every cent -- you can feed 8 people on one pizza, and still have leftovers for a midnight snack! Apples-to-Apples, it's a good value, and a great meal. more

The Best 7/25/2002

I have been to many different pizza places over the years and I thought that they were all really good. But then I had a single bite of Pizza Plus pizza and all of those other pizza shops faded in comparison. The pizza here is the best anywhere. I would recomend the supreme or the hawian. Enjoy your pizza. Pros: Tasty, Filling, Big more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Bexley Pizza Plus




FALL SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 12/30/2018

Editorial

  • The Scene
    Inside this unassuming carryout on East Main Street you'll find some of the best pizza in Columbus. Like most pizza places, it's got a counter, pizza ovens and a cooler full of...

  • 8/14/2003 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Mon 11am-10pm Sun, Tue-Thu 11am-10:30pm Fri-Sat 11am-12am
  • Payments:

    Discover, Visa, Cash, Master Card
  • Neighborhoods:

    Bexley Park, East Columbus
badge