JavaScript is not enabled.
Best-Made Shoes - 3 Reviews - 5143 Liberty Ave, Pittsburgh, PA - Shoe Store Reviews - Phone (412) 621-9363

Best-Made Shoes

5143 Liberty Ave
Pittsburgh, PA 15224
(412) 621-9363
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Main categories:

Shoe Store

Related categories:



( 1 )
( 2 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )


I tried on so many shoes in so many stores and must tell you that this store offers the best service and the best shoes! Have had heel pain for years and I was fitted with an ins...


All reviews seem positive

Editorial review from Citysearch 12/4/2014

With the excruciating pain I was experiencing due to plantar fasciitis, I paid a visit to Best Made Shoes. My wife also suffered from plantar fasciitis pain. The individual who waited on us (please note he was rather smug) recommended a Birkenstock orthotic for both my wife and I. When I asked him the price of the item, he indicated it was $70 per pair (for a total of $140.) Although I thought this was rather pricey, I moved forward with the purchase. The orthotic he recommended seems to be working well for me and I wanted to purchase another pair. I searched the internet and found the identical item on Ebay for $39.20!!! \r \r Talk about being taken advantage of!! Thanks for ripping me off, Mr. Gene Rosen - you'll never see me again!! more

Editorial review from Citysearch 7/2/2013

Wish I could give zero stars. Do not consider bringing your shoes here for repairs. Seriously, just don't. I brought a pair of cole haan wingtips there to have a scuff smoothed out in the leather and they PAINTED the entire wooden outer sole black. How does that happen? It was cherry brown.\r \r The customer service was pretty bad, no one had any idea why it happened, and they were not even apologetic. These are expensive shoes, too expensive for the flippant attitude I received. They offered to ""take a look at them"" but I would never trust them with my shoes again.\r \r Luckily, Joe's shoe repair downtown on 4th avenue could fix them.\r \r Seriously, don't bother going here or you will be sad and sorry. Your shoes deserve better.\r more

Great Shoes and Great Service! 12/20/2011

I tried on so many shoes in so many stores and must tell you that this store offers the best service and the best shoes! Have had heel pain for years and I was fitted with an insert right in the store. I bought 2 pairs of the most comfortable shoes that are also fashionable. The customer service was superb! Do yourself a favor and just go here FIRST! I will be buying all of my shoes there! more

Good luck here 4/11/2011

I've had heels repaired here on 3 separate visits and was satisfied with all the repairs. One was a pr of men's boots and the heels were quite worn down; that repair ($30) is indistinguishable from the original. The other two repairs were for women's heels - replacing the heel cap and reattaching a heel. Both times were good. Not particularly fast but good work and a fair price for repairs. more

Best-Made Shoes 10/15/2010

Great store with personal service. Best of all I have shoes that fit and support my feet! I have a narrow foot and it is just about impossible to find shoes in Pittsburgh. I love clogs and was able to find 2 pairs in narrow!! They also carry New Balance running shoes (my next purchase). more
< Previous 1 Next >

Owner Message

  • Pittsburgh's Only Specialty Shoe Store. Celebrating over 39 years of Exceptional Service. Pittsburgh's Birkenstock Headquarters. New Balance Procare Dealer. Largest Selection of Alegria & Finn Footwear. Custom made shoes, sandals and Orthotics made on site. Authorized Repair Center on-site. Medicare & HMO Provider for Diabetic Footwear. Drew Shoes. Board-Certified & Licensed Pedorthists, House Calls and much more.

Additional information

  • Neighborhoods: