JavaScript is not enabled.
Benny's Pizza - 6 Reviews - 968 Columbus Ave, Marysville, OH - Restaurants Reviews - Phone (512) 609-8338
top 10

Benny's Pizza

968 Columbus Ave
Marysville, OH 43040
(512) 609-8338
Incorrect info? Correct your listing


( 4 )
( 1 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 0 )


My husband and I have lived here a few years now and can say this is the best pizza in town. Just as good as the pizza you get in Columbus. We use carry out more often and y...


All reviews seem positive

Great pizza and environment .. Prices 6/27/2012

Great pizza and environment .. Prices are high. more

best pizza in town 9/3/2011

My husband and I have lived here a few years now and can say this is the best pizza in town. Just as good as the pizza you get in Columbus. We use carry out more often and you can get a soft serve ice cream cone for free when you pick up your food. Nice and refreshing on a hot summer day, even if it might ruin your dinner a bit. more

Best Pizza in area 2/6/2009

Hands down the best pizza in the area.....all fresh, no trucked in crusts, noting frozen (unlike Bostons).\r Great BBQ, live music every Friday and Saturday, bands vary wildly in style.\r Pros: The best around!! Great BBQ and Pizza Cons: Sometimes packed.....can be very busy more

Top notch pizza. Grrrreat ribs. 12/29/2006

Benny's has some of the best oven baked pizza in the area. You won't regret trying Benny's if you have been on the hunt for a decent pie in central Ohio. The pepperoni is loaded with toppings, so bear it in mind if you are a pepperoni fan.\r \r The ribs are also excellent, another local recipe. I don't hear as much about these, but in my opinion they are better than some of the better know ""chain"" rib joints in the Columbus area.\r \r This restaurant is usually very busy in the evening and they do not deliver, so if you are ordering carry-out be aware that there may be a long line at the cash register. The dining room is busy and it can be noisy in the evening, so it's not the spot for a quiet dinner. Overall, it's a must try if you are on the West side of town. Pros: Pizza is excellent. Ribs very good. Cons: Busy, slow carry out, noisy. more

One of the best pizza's you'll ever have 9/14/2006

I love Benny's and apparently so does everyone else in Marysville. It's the place to be on Friday and Saturday nights. Get there early cause it gets packed! Their newly expanded patio and outdoor bar is outstanding and it fills up. Great for watching sports, and you get to do it outside! They have pretty good bands on the weekend. Now as for their pizza - you'll be hooked. I've had hundreds of different pizza's and this is the best pizza ever. They've got tons of other goodies on their menu to choose from as well. It's just 15 minute drive from Dublin, you won't be sorry! more

Great little place. 2/8/2006

Husband discovered Benny's when he had the misfortune of working at the Honda plant in Marysville. At first I wasn't particularly blown away by their food, but it has definitely grown on me. Their pizza is really really good - plenty of cheese, a home-made tasting tomato sauce, and heaps of toppings. Husband loves their wings - the extra hot wings definitely live up to their name!I would recommend Benny's to anyone who likes decent pizza and cold beer at a great price. It's definitely worth the drive from Hilliard. Pros: Parking, Great value, Friendly folk Cons: V busy @ peak times, Sometimes smoky more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Benny's Pizza

15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 11/30/2017

Additional information

  • Payments:

    Visa, Master Card