Honestly, in the land where the bagel was born, why don't many NYC bagel places have any cream cheeses to choose from other than plain, veggie, scallion, and lox? Bagels on the Square is like hitting the motherload of flavored cream cheese. I would personally recommend a bagel sandwich w/ turkey & the jalapeno cream cheese, mmm... I purposely don't eat before I go down there just so I have an excuse to eat here.
Pros: lots of cream cheeses