I work in a jewelry store, and let me tell you, Maya is not as over-priced as most places around Austin. They have beautiful chunky rings made of turquoise, moonstone, onyx, and many other semi precious stones. One of the most expensive rings I saw in the store was $70 - that is really not bad, especially considering that all of their rings are shipped to their store from India. The price of gold and silver is always increasing. At the store where I work (a very well known and popular jewelry store... I'll keep it anonymous) you can't get a silver ring with a stone in it for less than $75, and that is for an extremely thin silver band with a very tiny stone, made right here in Texas (less money spent on shipping merchandise should mean cheaper prices, right?). I'm a fan of Maya!
Pros: Great rings, decent prices
Cons: Downtown - sometimes parking can be tough