JavaScript is not enabled.
Agata & Valentina - 19 Reviews - 1505 1st Ave, New York, NY - Italian Restaurants Reviews - Phone (212) 452-0690

Agata & Valentina

Claim
marker
1505 1st Ave (at East 79th Street)
New York, NY 10075
marker
(212) 452-0690
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Reviews

( 9 )
( 6 )
( 1 )
( 2 )
( 1 )

Best

MIXY checked me out. I didn't get that barking command to empty my own basket--unlike one major grocer whose name I will mention because they're so NOTORIOUSLY RUDE, Food Emporium...

Worst

good deli, good meat department but the prices are much too high, even for ny.

good but way overpriced 3/5/2012

good deli, good meat department but the prices are much too high, even for ny. more

Fresh Meat 6/9/2011

I don't come here that often, but that's not because I don't want to. You definitely get what you pay for and a visit to the meat department here is worth every penny. They actually have butchers and they know what they're talking about. I love the fresh pasta too. more

Questionable Cleanliness 9/26/2010

I have shopped there a few times and I like the fresh pastas. I walked by late a few nights ago and peered into the windows. I noticed mouse traps on the floors. The next morning, I saw some questionable droppings around the store. Raisins, I think not. I actually took the time to look into the open kitchen. Everyone in there is sweaty and I won't be surprised if sweat drops into the cooking. I bolted and I don't think I will be shopping there anymore. more

New York WITHOUT Attitude?! 9/24/2009

MIXY checked me out. I didn't get that barking command to empty my own basket--unlike one major grocer whose name I will mention because they're so NOTORIOUSLY RUDE, Food Emporium, avoid the 3rd Ave (they are the worst)--but rather MIXY chirpily emptied my items scanning quickly, and carefully handled fruit and delicate items, placing them gently aside to load on top of the hard items. I couldn't believe it. I realized I have become so accustomed to rudeness and have low expectations generally, that I would find her handling of groceries amazingly thoughtful. I must sound ridiculous, but it's so refreshing to go to a grocery store and NOBODY HAS NO ATTITUDE PROBLEM. That's saying a lot for NYC. The management is excellent. Hats off to them! Pros: Best Service in a grocery more

Great Gourmet Goodies 3/3/2009

We live a block away so this store is a constant temptation. It's expensive and crowded and the staff is poorly trained but there's a lot to choose from. On the down side, we can't seem to find a bread we like there, the hot prepared food can be so-so and the deli counter moves at the speed of grass growth. But the cold prepared food choices are better and with interesting seasonal choices. The fresh produce selections are top notch with great variety and quality. Looking for a specialty herb or unusual vegetable? You'll find it here. The cheese counter looks well stocked and dangerously delicious. Lots of prepared salads in individual containers make for quick selections for a great lunch or easy cold dinner. The white bean salad, wheatberry salad and cabbage salads are especially tasty. The line to pay is long but there are many registers and they move fast. Your trip to that register though, will take you past the dessert department with its many individually packed choices. As you wrestle with your willpower, you'll smell freshly baking pastries and look over a dizzying array of sweet choices but the flourless chocolate Gianduja is worthy of a 4 star restaurant and the mixed berry cake is another delectable favorite. more

Impeccable quality 11/10/2008

Walking into Agata and Valentina is like walking into a busy market in Tuscany. Immediatly you smell the bread from the bakery, the fresh fruit displays, any kind of cheese you could possibly imagaine, they eben make there own balsamic vinagar and olive oil. The meats and fish are fantasic. These is sooooo many products in such a small place, The only downside is all this great food there is no wine ot pair it with,\r A&V doesnt sell wine. Not even cooking wine. Cons: congested, no wine more

Quality is great but the staff are not knowledgeable 8/21/2007

I don't frequent at Agata & Valentina and now I remember why. I think their produce, imports, pasta's are fabulous but don't bother to ask a staff member that works there for any help. I was there this past weekend and I asked for calamari and lasagna and the person behind the counter didn't know what that was! I'm surprised that a store such as Agata & Valentina would hire people who don't know what they are selling. It got worse when I asked for a side of mariana sauce and the person next to her had to tell it what it was! The person next in line had the same problem. \r \r Very disappointing for their lack of knowledge for a speciality store on the UES! Their restaurant across the street is a totally different story. I can't believe it's the same owner!!! In reference to the store though, I think I'll make an extra trip to Murray Hill or another gourmet store for good service. Pros: Gourmet and fresh selections Cons: The staff don't know their products and how to help their customers more

Quintessential NYC Specialty Food Store 3/22/2007

Agata & Valentina is my favorite food store in the city! The produce is the first thing you see when you walk in and it's almost irresistable - beautiful, colorful displays of really unique seasonal finds, plus a great organic selection. I have always been really impressed with their meat and fish - it's really fresh and it makes me look good when I cook for family & friends. Their specialty items and imports like olive oils, honeys, and preserves are beautifully packaged and always a discovery - I am serious when I say that I've actually done Christmans shopping at Agata for family members out of town. The only down side to the place is that it's designed like a Sicilian marketplace with LOTS of stuff packed in, so it can get congested at the busy times, but luckily the line for the registers moves pretty quickly. Pros: Amazing products, reasonable prices for high quality, feels like a real Italian market Cons: Occasionally congested more

Super little market! 1/24/2006

Been a loyal customer of A&V for three years. PROS: Variety, with lots of special surprises tucked here and there - you just have to explore; Freshness of all products; Delicious home-made soups; Wonderful fresh pastas; Good bakery; Great meat dept; EXCELLENT seafood department; Staff mostly helpful and knowledgeable. CONS: It's true, some staff is rude, in particular the stock guys and check-out girls - but that can generally be overcome with a smile; Checkout line can be long, but it moves quickly - just pass the time admiring the specialites. OVERALL: Price for quality is fair. MUCH better than Eli's, which is outrageous! Buy your basics (milk, juice, eggs, etc) at a regular market. Go to A&V for special products, vegetables, meat, and seafood. (Of course, Whole Foods is grocery store paradise. But who has the time to make the trek?) Pros: Freshness, Variety, Convenience Cons: Some rude staff more

Is the best 9/25/2005

no words ....only try this store & you will agree with me!!! more

New York Gourmet 11/16/2004

I've visited Agata & Valentina on several occasions, each time something new was waiting. I highly recommend them for the best choice of gourmet breads, cheeses, desserts, as well as an excellent choice of wines. Agata & Valentina has a unique selection is most certainly the quintessential East Side neighborhood market. Pros: variety, location more

declious and expensive 10/23/2004

While not standing out from other gourmet food stores in the area, Agata and Valentina is worth the splurge now and again. Their produce is consistently fresh and there is a beautiful assortment of cheeses. The meat is some of the freshest around but the lines can be long and the customer service lackluster. If you can look past these things, you are sure to enjoy a quality sunday meal. Nicole Brennan Pros: fresh meat, great cheese selectio Cons: , bad customer service more

Owner reviews? 5/15/2004

First, the lines. LONG and for what? Rich people must either enjoy waiting, paying too much or eating bad food if this store is so popular. Oh, and the staff is NOT friendly at least the one I asked where something was and she said, ""Over there."" and went back to talking to her coworker. Pros: good cheese Cons: , small variety more

Perfecto! 11/23/2003

This may not be the cheapest store around or the most delicious, but it is certainly the most fun grocery on the upper east side. There is even a ready-made cafe in the front that serves wine, with a two-for-one during happy hour! So, sit back and enjoy the european feel of this neighborhood market. Pros: Variety, Wine, Convenience Cons: Prices, Limited selection, Staff more

LOVE this place 10/14/2003

Absolutely great market. Fresh foods, all quality. My ""go to"" market on the UES. more

great neighborhood treat 1/19/2003

overall, very good value the vegetables are quite fresh the sliced meats are very good value coffee is vg and moderately priced lines can be long but move fast Pros: much cheaper than eli, lunch boxes are fun more

Nice Produce & a great Cheese Department 12/18/2002

Agata is a great place to go in the neighborhood for produce (heirloom tomotoes, wild mushrooms and jicama) and superb cheese. They make their own mozzarella. Although pricey, and super-long lines during peak times, they are a good alternative when Citarella is too busy. Pros: Variety, Selection, Produce more

7 8/27/2002

Nobody's perfect. Sorry for the cliche! Great people, smiling faces? Who said that? Probably the owners. There are very few great people in this world, and if you are lucky enough to come across just one, then you are truly blessed. So I don't think they are all hanging out at Agata & Valentina waiting to serve on you with a smile on their faces. It must have been a dream you had about the store in its perfection! And I have seen some customers ask the workers questions like...What do I put in my salad? What is low fat? Can I put this in a microwave? They can be pathetic. An affluent store in an affluent neighborhood which attracts all kinds of people, but 3/thirds put on airs, so they're all pretty much the same people. Pros: there is always food Cons: crowed when Im there more

Best Food, Best Service, Best Prices 8/8/2002

Agata's got it all, from the best produce (at far lower prices than the local Food Emporium) to the best meats. The staff there is great, in particular the butcher and the cheese guys. I do all my weekly marketing here (save stuff like toiler paper) and it's cheaper than the supermarket. You can't beat it. Oh, go early in the morning. The place gets nuts as the day wears on. Pros: Great Products, Great Prices, Great Service Cons: Crowded more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Agata & Valentina




SPRING SALE!!!:
20% OFF all yearly plans
Use spring at checkout. Expires 6/30/2018

Editorial

  • The Scene
    Along with Grace's Marketplace, the Vinegar Factory, and Gourmet Garage, Agata & Valentina helps define the Upper East Side as gourmet grocery central. A relative newcomer to...

  • 8/14/2003 Provided by Citysearch

Additional information

  • Hours:

    8:00 AM - 8:30 PM 7 Days a Week
  • Payments:

    Master Card, Visa
  • Neighborhoods:

    Midtown, Yorkville, Upper East Side
badge