I am in charge of a fundraisng event at my daughter's school and I use Advance Novelty A LOT! They have a great selection of different party supplies, and the thing I like best about them are the prices- they are great! I love browsing the store, but they also have a website where everyone can shop! If you need a decoration for almost any occasion than this is the place for you! If you live in SE Michigan they also rent carnival style games for between $20-$45 a day (or you can check out their selections for ideas!)
more