We stayed at the NY-NY last fall, and had the misfortunate of eating at America twice. It wasn't our first choice- it was just the only restaurant open that late at night. We had been drinking all night and yet the food was still terrible. The sandwiches and breakfast items were poor, and even quality of service was not good.
Only pros: open 24 hours a day, and it's so huge that you'll never wait for a table.
Pros: open 24 hours, big menu, plenty of tables
Cons: bad food, slow service
more