Unbelievably, other tables came and went before we even got our 1 appetizer of fried calamari. Then other tables came and went before we got our two pies. I was thisclose to leaving NO TIP but I... More

Unbelievably, other tables came and went before we even got our 1 appetizer of fried calamari. Then other tables came and went before we got our two pies. I was thisclose to leaving NO TIP but I decided to ask another waitress if they pool tips. They do pool tips, so I left 20%, otherwise I would have left nothing for Carla our waitress. I have never had such horrible service, but please note that the other waitresses were doing a great job. Great food. I would definitely go back, but if Carla waits on us, I'd have to politely ask for another waitress. Pros: FOOD Cons: WAITRESS AND WAIT
Less

I've been here twice and thought it was great both times. Would definatly go back. The pies always come out quick ard are perfectly cooked. Pros: Great Crust

I've been here twice and thought it was great both times. Would definatly go back. The pies always come out quick ard are perfectly cooked. Pros: Great Crust
Less

How this place continues to be rated best pizza on SI is beyond me. Joe & Pat's is way better all around. Yes, it's a different style of pizza but taste is taste. I guess at $11 a pie it's a bargain... More

How this place continues to be rated best pizza on SI is beyond me. Joe & Pat's is way better all around. Yes, it's a different style of pizza but taste is taste. I guess at $11 a pie it's a bargain these days. Salvatore of Soho on Hylan has an excellent coal fired pie too. $18 for the pie but a delicious pie. Pros: Good crust Cons: Too much cheese, not enough sauce.. Mediocre taste
Less

It was our first (and last) time there. The place was jammed and this seemed to jive with the "legend" that they had fantastic pizza. It was a long wait for our table. The green salad was very... More

It was our first (and last) time there. The place was jammed and this seemed to jive with the "legend" that they had fantastic pizza. It was a long wait for our table. The green salad was very generous in size and fresh . We ordered two pies, a sausage/meatball and a mushroom/onion; they were terrible. There was barely any flavor, the entire crust was over cooked to a hard crisp and ingredients appeared to be used very sparingly. We debated sending them back but the pies on nearby tables appeared to be in the same shape and we were not hopeful for a significant improvement. The waitress had no problem getting us $drinks$ but took forever with 2 reminders to get us water. Perhaps they were legends in their time but that time has passed. Pros: Generous fresh garden salad Cons: bad pizza, long wait, difficult parking
Less

Personally I love thin pizza. This place makes great thin crust pizza.

Personally I love thin pizza. This place makes great thin crust pizza.
Less

This place is excellent. The pizza is by far way better than Brothers. The wait can be a little long for pick-up as they do not deliver, and the dining area is always packed... but it is well... More

This place is excellent. The pizza is by far way better than Brothers. The wait can be a little long for pick-up as they do not deliver, and the dining area is always packed... but it is well worth the wait. Great family place.
Less

I dont know what all the rave is about or who is responsable for it but this place aint that good. The crust is raw a disgusting. The sauce is ok the cheese is typical. I ordered the pizza well-done... More

I dont know what all the rave is about or who is responsable for it but this place aint that good. The crust is raw a disgusting. The sauce is ok the cheese is typical. I ordered the pizza well-done because I noticed the pizza's being brought to other tables were undone and "raw". Well when ours came out it still wasnt cooked right. I wanted to send it back but the waitress said I would still have to pay for this pizza and she just rambled on how the pizza maker wouldnt be able to cook it any more or else he might burn it. This is the one of the worst pizza's on Staten Island. Pros: NONE Cons: The food and the service
Less

One of the few pizzeria's left on the Island. Really cool place my kids love it and I love it, we go about once a month they are good to us in there. Good value good food.

One of the few pizzeria's left on the Island. Really cool place my kids love it and I love it, we go about once a month they are good to us in there. Good value good food.
Less

I've been there twice and was disappointed. I ordered the calamari and there was no squid in it! and the pizza pies(i had the garbage pie and magarita pie) were no big deal. I had frozen pizza that... More

I've been there twice and was disappointed. I ordered the calamari and there was no squid in it! and the pizza pies(i had the garbage pie and magarita pie) were no big deal. I had frozen pizza that tasted better.
Less

What kind of pizza do you like? If you like pizza that is more traditionally Italian (thin crust) Then this is your place. I like New York style pizza. The place is very crowded so call in your... More

What kind of pizza do you like? If you like pizza that is more traditionally Italian (thin crust) Then this is your place. I like New York style pizza. The place is very crowded so call in your order first and they don't deliver.
Less