Back in the dotcom days Extreme Pizza was awesome! Whenever we were working late at the office, we'd bust out the corporate card and get dinner for the workaholics (most of us). And Extreme was... More

Back in the dotcom days Extreme Pizza was awesome! Whenever we were working late at the office, we'd bust out the corporate card and get dinner for the workaholics (most of us). And Extreme was usually at the top of the list. I built up quite the opinion of them in my head. Since then, my roomies and I have ordered from them every so often, and it's never quite lived up to what they used to deliver. "We just caught them on a bad night.", I'd think to myself. But eventually I realized that, since the crash, EVERY night has been a bad night, In 2000, I'd have given them four stars easily, maybe even five. Now, two is the best they can merit.
Less

The only thing extreme about Extreme Pizza is its mediocrity. Oh snap, did I just say that? Well, they kinda set themselves up for that didn't they? By not making good pizza. If I had a place called... More

The only thing extreme about Extreme Pizza is its mediocrity. Oh snap, did I just say that? Well, they kinda set themselves up for that didn't they? By not making good pizza. If I had a place called Extreme anything, whatever it was I made would be crazy. Your head would be reeling. It would effect you emotionally and physically. Or in the very least, leave an impression. The one positive thing I'll say is that once, a homeless guy gave us a leftover pizza that they'd given him for free for helping take out the trash or something. So, there is something to say about crappy pizza because can you imagine just giving away good pizza?
Less

We ordered the Mr. Pestato head pizza and their twisted sticks. Nothing was really that good. While the idea of pesto, potatoes, feta and such things was really amazing there was some sort of... More

We ordered the Mr. Pestato head pizza and their twisted sticks. Nothing was really that good. While the idea of pesto, potatoes, feta and such things was really amazing there was some sort of weird aftertaste involved in the mix. The bread sticks were pretty bland and were basically just pizza crust. It was also very expensive! I would still recommend trying their pizzas for the experience, I mean where else can you get a hummus pizza? However I don't think I'll try them again.
Less