We visited Tribecca Grill for the American Graffitti wine tasting, & stayed for dinner. Our meal ($35 pre-fixe) was fine, but our wine service was botched. We ordered a 1991 Shafer Hillside Select... More

We visited Tribecca Grill for the American Graffitti wine tasting, & stayed for dinner. Our meal ($35 pre-fixe) was fine, but our wine service was botched. We ordered a 1991 Shafer Hillside Select Cabernet, and asked that it not be decanted. Unfortunately, our sommelier decided to ignore our request--b/c a couple of pieces of cork had fallen into the wine, and she couldn't figure out how to get them out, other than to decant the entire bottle--which is just ridiculous. Sadly, the wine's nose was gone, and it showed much less powerfully (and less nicely) than the tiny amount in the bottle that wasn't decanted. We didn't get an apology, nor a price concession. $225/bottle is a lot to pay to ignore a customer request and damage their wine. Our Peruvian waiter was very nice, and the food was ok, but forget about ordering an expensive bottle of wine there. Pros: $35 pre-fixe (@ times Cons: wine service, customer service
Less

went there for restaurant week. had to wait 20 minutes even though we had a reservation. our waiter was great in that he took down our order for all 3 courses once we were seated and everything came... More

went there for restaurant week. had to wait 20 minutes even though we had a reservation. our waiter was great in that he took down our order for all 3 courses once we were seated and everything came out right on time. food overall was good but nothing that i'd go back for. for the prices that are on the regular menu we were expecting something more upscale and less generic. Pros: great service Cons: avg food
Less

I've been to many restaurants in NYC for restaurant week and Tribeca Grill was a great choice. The food was good quality throughout the 3 courses and the service was impeccable. I will return if I... More

I've been to many restaurants in NYC for restaurant week and Tribeca Grill was a great choice. The food was good quality throughout the 3 courses and the service was impeccable. I will return if I am in the neighborhood and I'm definitely curious about the rest of their menu. Pros: Large Space , Great Service Cons: Loud
Less

I went here during restaurant week and although their restaurant week menu was impressive I saw the Herb Chicken dish and could not resist. It was absolutely phenomenal. One of the best chicken... More

I went here during restaurant week and although their restaurant week menu was impressive I saw the Herb Chicken dish and could not resist. It was absolutely phenomenal. One of the best chicken dishes I've ever had! The chicken was tender and fresh with just the right amount of flavor from the herbs and the porcini sauce was delectable. My friend ordered the quaill appetizer which was also excellent and the sea bass- very good. You can't go wrong here and considering that it's categorized as very expensive I really felt like it was cheap for the quality of food we received. If you're a New Yorker and you haven't been here, GO... NOW!!! Pros: Excellent Food, Good Service Cons: Noisy, Seating isn't Private
Less

Tribeca Grill has extended their restaurant week menu so go while you have the chance! A friend and I had a delightful experience. We made reservations for 8:30pm but were not seated until 9 (so err... More

Tribeca Grill has extended their restaurant week menu so go while you have the chance! A friend and I had a delightful experience. We made reservations for 8:30pm but were not seated until 9 (so err on the early side when making ressies). Our waiter was very polite and helpful. My appetizer of endive and bleu cheese salad was a surprisingly large serving which balanced the striped bass entree (served on a bed of vegetables). My friend had the special soup and her cheese ravioli looked divine (it was garnished with yummy spinach). Our desserts were the perfect ending - she had a chocolate truffle cheesecake while my warm apple tart was delicious (this coming from someone who is not a fan of apples!). The atmosphere was casual, the waiters friendly, and the food above average. We will definitely be going back!
Less

We decided to check out Tribeca Grill for Restaurant Week becuase the menu looked pleasantly different. What a mistake! The salad and dessert were sub-par but the entrees were honestly horrible. I... More

We decided to check out Tribeca Grill for Restaurant Week becuase the menu looked pleasantly different. What a mistake! The salad and dessert were sub-par but the entrees were honestly horrible. I ordered the black bass which came out smelling fishy and my friend ordered the shortback ribs which he said tasted like "beef jerky". When we asked the waiter what was up he said that they just "could not provide it was too costly to provide there usally quality of food" and that "most people who come to Restaurant Week are from Jersey and won't be repeat customers so it wouldn't really affect their future business". To say the least we will never go back here again. Two nights later I had dinner at another Restaurant Week participant and it was AMAZING!!! I will back and pay the full $65 pre-fix price. Isn't that what Restaurant Week is about? Pros: Nothing Cons: Food, Atmosphere, The Whole Experience
Less

I have been lucky enough to dine here several times a year. The menu has a nice selection, and everything on it is well prepared and tastie. I have also noticed an improved waitstaff over the last... More

I have been lucky enough to dine here several times a year. The menu has a nice selection, and everything on it is well prepared and tastie. I have also noticed an improved waitstaff over the last few years, less attitude, better attention, and friendlier staff. It's a great experience. Pros: Great Food, Friendly Waitstaff Cons: None
Less

Just visited the Tribeca Grill with a group of 6. Nice place. We were seated in the small back dining room. Would've preferred a table in the larger open area. Food was very good. My filet was... More

Just visited the Tribeca Grill with a group of 6. Nice place. We were seated in the small back dining room. Would've preferred a table in the larger open area. Food was very good. My filet was dry and overcooked. I ordered Medium-Rare and it was well done. The waiter warned a group member that the filet was dry....and to order the NY STRIP....I should've listened. Other than that...Seared Ahi Tuna was excellent, as was the spinach. Most group members were very happy. Wine list here is huge. Interesting art work on the walls. Overall, a worthwhile establishment. Pros: SERVICE, MENU SELECTION, ATMOSPHERE Cons: FEW MENU SELECTIONS
Less

Visited the restaurant on vacation - we were very pleased! Loved the atmosphere - NY, but casual. We ordered from the prix fixe menu ($39 for three courses) and loved every bite. Blue Cheese and... More

Visited the restaurant on vacation - we were very pleased! Loved the atmosphere - NY, but casual. We ordered from the prix fixe menu ($39 for three courses) and loved every bite. Blue Cheese and Endive Salad, Goat Cheese Ravioli was to die for, and the absolute BEST cheesecake that we had ever tasted. Super wine list can accommodate anyone - with help, we chose a very low priced bottle - $40 (which still was highly recommended from the staff) which was wonderful. For more discerning wine drinkers, bottles go up to $2,250! I would definitely go back, and recommend it to anyone looking for a superb meal out.
Less

I was very disappointed in the food and atmosphere.My sister ordered the duck & the sauce was so bad that it took away the taste in the duck so my sister had to scrape the sauce off the duck,so she... More

I was very disappointed in the food and atmosphere.My sister ordered the duck & the sauce was so bad that it took away the taste in the duck so my sister had to scrape the sauce off the duck,so she could eat it, i was also shocked that the food on your plate was so little and so expensive i was hungrey the next two hours,also the dessert menue was such confusion to read i dont care how fancy it was how do you not have cheese cake! also the seats were to close together i felt cramped.How ever the service was quick & the wine was good.
Less