Sign in or  Join Judy's Book to contribute

Business Details

One Fish Two Fish

(more)
1399 Madison Ave
New York, New York 10029
(212) 369-5677    Is this your business?
Neighborhood: East Harlem, Uptown, East Harlem (El Barrio)
Rate this Business
Rate this business
Rate this Business Write a Review
RSS Subscribe to updates
 
Share |
  Rating: 2.7
5 star:
 
18%
(4)
4 star:
 
13%
(3)
3 star:
 
18%
(4)
2 star:
 
22%
(5)
1 star:
 
27%
(6)
Totals:
Reviews: 22
Rating: 2.7
Share your thoughts with other customers
Overview
Photo & Videos
Owner Message
Maps & Directions
Look Around

WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING ABOUT ONE FISH TWO FISH - NEW YORK
Editorial Review by Citysearch Editors Contributor
Popular seafood restaurant with boisterous bar offers nautical atmosphere, happy hour, daily brunch, late-night dining to casual local groups. more from the editor »
THE DETAILS ON ONE FISH TWO FISH - NEW YORK
Categories:
Restaurants

Payment Options:
American Express, Discover, Visa, Master Card

citysearch
Some content provided by
  1-Glance Local Reputation
Judy's Book:
  CitySearch:
  Other: N/A
The most helpful favorable review
citysearch c.

best price for crab legs in NYC
I'm not to sure what the other reviewers were expecting from 1 Fish, 2 Fish. If you are expecting great seafood at a great price, then this is your...
by osirisdb7
   More
See more 5 star, 4 star reviews
The most helpful critical review
citysearch c.

The food was sub-par and the service was worse
We stopped in one afternoon because my wife's been eyeing the place. We were quickly seated at a table whose paper place mats/menus still bore the...
by citysearch c.
 More
See more 3 star, 2 star, 1 star reviews
citysearch c.

Stay Away!!!   by ToriS 6 months ago
Sloppy personnel, arogant staff, they act like you need them. Almost like you have to beg for food. I went with my girlfriend for dinner but changed our minds after the lousy service. We had 2... More
Was this review useful? 0   0
 
citysearch c.

My absolute favorite resturant.....   by Deatrice 10 months ago
You gotta love atmosphere to love this spot. The food isn't wonderful, but it's cool for the crowd they have. My signature dish is Shrimp Scampi w/ rice and for dessert....well I'mma wing it this... More
Was this review useful? 0   0
 
citysearch c.

Terrible...Worst in Manhattan!   by ericdolf 1 year ago
This may be the worst restaurant I've ever been to! Not only was the food the most disgusting I've ever eaten in a New York City restaurant, the service was the 2nd worst I've ever experienced... More
Was this review useful? 0   0
 
citysearch c.

One Fish Two fish by Ashley H. at InsiderPages   by Citysearch User 1 year ago
One Fish Two Fish is very clean.They food is delicious.You also will not be waiting very long for your food. The waiters are very friendly. If your looking for a nice restaurant thats clean and... More
Was this review useful? 0   0
 
citysearch c.

Good Food by Roy L. at InsiderPages   by Citysearch User 1 year ago
The staff a this restaurant is welcoming. The layout is not exactly unique but it is OK. The food is generally served with in a reasonable waiting period. The Salmon is just delicious which makes it... More
Was this review useful? 0   0
 
citysearch c.

Slow Fish   by ItsBernice 1 year ago
The food & service is terrible ... the ambiance of the restaurant however is great. The food is usually bland or over cooked and the service is dismal. As long as they take to bring you your food... More
Was this review useful? 0   0
 
citysearch c.

Not so great by Laura L. at InsiderPages   by Citysearch User 1 year ago
Yes, they offer drinks with lunch, and the $9.95 lunch prices are pretty decent for the area, but it's not worth it for the surly wait staff who forget about you completely, or treat you horribly.... More
Was this review useful? 0   0
 
citysearch c.

A strange fish...   by blondbluey 2 years ago
A very casual restaurant in all respects of service and decor. After guided to our table no menus were presented so my friend and I looked at the placemats and saw many listings but no info on the... More
Was this review useful? 0   0
 
citysearch c.

Reasonable, not exceptional seafood   by hickland 2 years ago
Good service. Found the standard bread too buttery. Calamari was too greasy and more chewy than crunchy. Steamed fish arrived with very little preparation and an excessive amount of a highly... More
Was this review useful? 0   0
 
citysearch c.

Pretty Good by Crystal W. at InsiderPages   by Citysearch User 2 years ago
I have never had any complaints. The restaurant is always clean and in perfect condition. They have great food. The staff is always friendly too. Yes, it is usually packed, but that is a good thing.... More
Was this review useful? 0   0
 
prev 1 2 3 next
One Fish Two Fish
New York, NY
Related Businesses
Businesses You May Like