in New York, NY
My Book
Post Review
Sign in
or
Join Judy's Book
to contribute
in or near
We tried to guess where you are. Click to change.
Home
>
New York
>
New York
>
Food & Dining
>
Restaurants
> Picholine
Business Details
Top 10 in New York
»
Coffee Shops
.
Dentists
.
Doctors
.
Dry Cleaning
.
More Topics »
Your vote has been saved successfully. Thank you.
You cannot vote twice for a Review within 3 minutes.
Picholine
Category:
Restaurants
(
more
)
Category:
Food & Dining
,
Restaurants
,
European Restaurants
,
French Restaurants
(
less
)
35 W 64th St # Fl1
New York, New York 10023
(212) 724-8585
Is this your business?
Get Maps & Directions »
Neighborhood:
Midtown, Lincoln Square
Rate this business
Add to my Favorites
Add to my Rejects
Write a Review
Subscribe to updates
Share
|
Reviews
Trends
Editorials
Rating: 4.0
More
Less
5 star:
0%
(0)
4 star:
100%
(1)
3 star:
0%
(0)
2 star:
0%
(0)
1 star:
0%
(0)
Totals:
Reviews:
1
Rating:
4.0
Share your thoughts with other customers
Totals:
Activities:
2
Share your thoughts with other customers
A new color scheme and a revamped menu make a bid for continued relevance at this stately Upper West Side classic. Contributor
In Short
Even after a recent lavender-heavy makeover, Picholine's high ceilings and glittering chandeliers maintain an imposing old-world vi...
more from the editor »
Share your thoughts with other customers
Overview
Owner Message
Maps & Directions
Look Around
WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING ABOUT PICHOLINE - NEW YORK
A new color scheme and a revamped menu make a bid for continued relevance at this stately Upper West Side classic. Contributor
In Short
Even after a recent lavender-heavy makeover, Picholine's high ceilings and glittering chandeliers maintain an imposing old-world vi...
more from the editor »
Message from the Owner »
Read User Reviews »
THE DETAILS ON PICHOLINE - NEW YORK
Categories:
Restaurants
Payment Options:
American Express, Discover, Diner's Club, Visa, Master Card
MORE INFO ON PICHOLINE - NEW YORK
Get Maps & Directions
What's Nearby - Look Around
Menu Items
View other
Restaurants
in
New York
First member to review:
Read Susan S.'s Book
Check out
deals in and around New York
This week's
Top 10 in New York
People who viewed this also viewed:
Hanbat Restaurant
Kum Gang Sang
Men Kui Tei
Street View
Heading over?
Make a reservation
Driving Directions
From
To
This business listing hasn't yet been claimed by the owner.
Is this your business?
Some content provided by
Reviews
(1)
Trends
(2)
Editorials
(1)
1-Glance Local Reputation
Judy's Book:
CitySearch:
N/A
Other:
N/A
The most helpful favorable review
Don't Come for the Ambiance
I am actually embarrassed to be reviewing (giving a 4 star) to a restaurant that has such terrible decor and layout, but the one thing that will...
by Susan S.
More
I am actually embarrassed to be reviewing (giving a 4 star) to a restaurant that has such terrible decor and layout, but the one thing that will tell you is that the food is that DARN GOOD. Bring your Gold or Platinum card, because the meal and beverages will set you back a good deal. Our party of 6 came out to about $200 per person. The cheese course was a highlight (that you should expect from Terrance Brennan) and the choice of game was nice and wide for any hunter/fan of hunted food. Buckshot may be seen in some entrées. My recommendations: Chestnut soup Venison Wild Hare Pheasant Apple tart of any kind The Le Reve from Domaine Carneros is very reasonably priced, fyi. I do not recommend the lobster appetizer - very small portion and the lobster itself gets lost in the other flavors it is mixed with in the dish. The decor is terrible (imagine eating a gourmet meal in the same hotel restaurant that you ate your $9.95 breakfast buffet) and one must walk through the service area to go down stairs to (usually) a line waiting for the bathroom. Avoid the toilets and enjoy the food and the company you bring!
by Susan S.
Less
See more 5 star,
4 star
reviews
Looks like all the reviews are favorable
If you feel otherwise,
create your own review
Don't Come for the Ambiance
by
Susan S.
I am actually embarrassed to be reviewing (giving a 4 star) to a restaurant that has such terrible decor and layout, but the one thing that will tell you is that the food is that DARN GOOD. Bring...
More
Was this review useful?
0
0
Report a problem
I am actually embarrassed to be reviewing (giving a 4 star) to a restaurant that has such terrible decor and layout, but the one thing that will tell you is that the food is that DARN GOOD. Bring your Gold or Platinum card, because the meal and beverages will set you back a good deal. Our party of 6 came out to about $200 per person. The cheese course was a highlight (that you should expect from Terrance Brennan) and the choice of game was nice and wide for any hunter/fan of hunted food. Buckshot may be seen in some entrées. My recommendations: Chestnut soup Venison Wild Hare Pheasant Apple tart of any kind The Le Reve from Domaine Carneros is very reasonably priced, fyi. I do not recommend the lobster appetizer - very small portion and the lobster itself gets lost in the other flavors it is mixed with in the dish. The decor is terrible (imagine eating a gourmet meal in the same hotel restaurant that you ate your $9.95 breakfast buffet) and one must walk through the service area to go down stairs to (usually) a line waiting for the bathroom. Avoid the toilets and enjoy the food and the company you bring!
by
Susan S.
Report a problem
Less
prev
1
next
Business Activities
Don't Come for the Ambiance
4 stars
"I am actually embarrassed to be reviewing (giving a 4 star) to a restaurant that has such terrible decor and layout, but..."
See Review
on 12/17/2006
Business listing was created. Share your thoughts every visit.
on 9/5/2005
prev
1
next
Editorials
A new color scheme and a revamped menu make a bid for continued relevance at this stately Upper West Side classic. Contributor
on 04-04-2007
In Short
Even after a recent lavender-heavy makeover, Picholine's high ceilings and glittering chandeliers maintain an imposing old-world vibe that's still in sync with the room's moneyed crowd. But with the exception of a few options on the "classics" menu--the renowned cheese plate, for example--chef Terrance Brennan has completely revamped the seasonally changing, Mediterranean-focused menu. Twists abound in dishes like scallop sashimi with watermelon relish, "bacon and eggs" made with polenta, tuna and truffle toast, and huckleberry-kissed venison.
prev
1
next
Back to Top
Picholine
New York, NY
Related Businesses
More
Less
Cafe Greco
7 Reviews
New York, New York
Tea & Sympathy
55 Reviews
New York, New York
Saigon Bahn Mi
1 Review
New York, New York
The Pump Energy Food
2 Reviews
New York, New York
Kum Gang Sang
47 Reviews
New York, New York
Businesses You May Like
More
Less
Fat Black Pussycat
170 Reviews
New York, New York
Corner Bistro
211 Reviews
New York, New York
230 Fifth
240 Reviews
New York, New York
One if by Land, Two if by Sea
220 Reviews
New York, New York
Dylan Prime
161 Reviews
New York, New York
Related Deals
$3.00 OFF Any Large Pie at Papou's Pizza
15% Off Any Meal ($10 Minimum) at Piazza/wrap & Roll
15% OFF Any Order Of $15.00. Delivery Only. at Chai
50% Off Pizza at Squisito Pizza & Catering
Free Delivery $20 minimum cash only at Bella Luna
Free Delivery at Prem-on Thai Restaurant
Free Delivery at Sala Thai
Look For Our Menu On-Line at Ej's Luncheonette East
$50 Off Each Blind or Shade Purchased No Limit! at Horizon Window Treatments
30% Off Custom Draperies & Valances & Swags at Horizon Window Treatments
New Business Listings in New York, NY
Jordan Insurance Agency
J & V Audio Inc
Kove Brothers Hardware
Best Weaving & Mending Inc
Midtown 57th St. Foot & Ankle Specialists
Manhattan Dental Enterprise
Royzman Yakov
J C Painting & Construction
Richard Sussman Attorney/Mediator
Hunkamania - Male Strip Club
Latest Reviews in New York, NY
Poorly Organized, Very Long Wait, Too Many Patients Booked For One Time
From Laurie
From Sissy
If you want modern art, this is the right place
Great Moving Experience
From Anne in NYC
My Favorite NYC Restaurant
Pleasant, helpful, custom orders
Aquarium Professionals!
Beware!
1