Very upscale restaurant w/ no dress code. Presentation is excellent and so is the bar. Pros: Food Presentation, Menu, bar Cons: No dresscode

Very upscale restaurant w/ no dress code. Presentation is excellent and so is the bar. Pros: Food Presentation, Menu, bar Cons: No dresscode
Less

I was seated promptly. The apps were good. Fennel soup was da nuts, Terrine rocked, risotto was bland. Entrees were outstanding Rabbit & the Squab cooked to perfection.

I was seated promptly. The apps were good. Fennel soup was da nuts, Terrine rocked, risotto was bland. Entrees were outstanding Rabbit & the Squab cooked to perfection.
Less

The Gotham Grill definately lived up to reviews I had read. Very upscale New York. The lamb chops were superb. The goat cheese ravioli was exquisite. Food presentation, ambiance, and service... More

The Gotham Grill definately lived up to reviews I had read. Very upscale New York. The lamb chops were superb. The goat cheese ravioli was exquisite. Food presentation, ambiance, and service were top drawer. A Must Dine...
Less

My favourite restaurant is no more. My daughter took me for dinner last night. The tuna tartare was chunky and toatally bland. The Sweetbreads were burnt, and overcooked. The squab was good but not... More

My favourite restaurant is no more. My daughter took me for dinner last night. The tuna tartare was chunky and toatally bland. The Sweetbreads were burnt, and overcooked. The squab was good but not outstanding as was the seafood salad. My pumpkin mousse tasted as if it had been around for a few days. The service was very pleasant if not observant. This used to be a vow what incredible food place. Now it is what a pretty presentation. At these prices there are many other places that serve better food. Pros: lovely hostess Cons: the food
Less

It was the night before thanksgiving and my mother's birthday. My sister was flying in to surprise Mom. The staff was gracious enough to keep her arrival a secret by letting us wait at the bar and... More

It was the night before thanksgiving and my mother's birthday. My sister was flying in to surprise Mom. The staff was gracious enough to keep her arrival a secret by letting us wait at the bar and holding our table for us until she and our father arrived 45 minutes late (delayed flight). The food was outstanding -- I inhaled the venison chop that was (barely) cooked to perfection and the bite I stole of my husband's duck was equally wonderful. Even though we started dinner almost an hour late, no one rushed us and dinner was exquisite. Pros: great food, wonderful service Cons: crowded tables
Less

Every now and then I like to enjoy a lovely fine restaurant and I decided to try Gotham. The service was great! The Captain was attentive & polite, unlike most NYC restaurant service employees. ... More

Every now and then I like to enjoy a lovely fine restaurant and I decided to try Gotham. The service was great! The Captain was attentive & polite, unlike most NYC restaurant service employees. The service was wonderful from the minute I walked through the door. I wish I was able to dine there a little longer than I did. The food was tasty, creative and well seasoned. Yes...Gotham is pricey but this is NYC and the food and service was worth the visit.
Less

Gotham is quite expensive, but the service and food are flawless. There are no vegetarian items on the menu, but when I requested that the chef make something meat-free for me, he came through with... More

Gotham is quite expensive, but the service and food are flawless. There are no vegetarian items on the menu, but when I requested that the chef make something meat-free for me, he came through with a dish just as delicious and pretty as those my friends were eating. Pros: food, service, ambiance Cons: price
Less

My wonderful boyfriend took me to the Gotham Bar and Grill for my 40th birthday and I was the most wonderful experience! The atmosphere is incredible and the food...selection, presentation, and... More

My wonderful boyfriend took me to the Gotham Bar and Grill for my 40th birthday and I was the most wonderful experience! The atmosphere is incredible and the food...selection, presentation, and taste are incredible. It was the perfect ending to a perfect day. I will, someday soon, to treat myself to another wonderful experience there.
Less

Very nicely decorated. Very spacious feel. Excellent food with professional but friendly service. The nice looking men with suits doesn't hurt either.

Very nicely decorated. Very spacious feel. Excellent food with professional but friendly service. The nice looking men with suits doesn't hurt either.
Less

This is a pricey place to dine in the evening, but the prix fixe lunch offers superb value. A nice twist is their lunchtime wine menu (all at $20.02) for tasting wines, half bottles, and full... More

This is a pricey place to dine in the evening, but the prix fixe lunch offers superb value. A nice twist is their lunchtime wine menu (all at $20.02) for tasting wines, half bottles, and full bottles. I arrived in shorts/t-shirt after a morning sightseeing, and changed on arrival (my idea not theirs). They were relaxed enough that I'm sure it wouldn't have been a problem to stay as I was. Service was very attentive, but not pushy. The waiter really knew his job - he didn't miss anything and, once told, remembered my husband was deaf in one ear & made sure he always spoke from the correct side. The food was excellent - good fresh ingredients, prepared well, and served stylishly. The room was nothing special - spacious, comfortable, not memorable. Would definitely come here again. Pros: Good food, Good value
Less