just not impressed with either the service or the food so was startled to read the editor's review above. the whole of my group thought that while the place is adequate in terms of style and... More

just not impressed with either the service or the food so was startled to read the editor's review above. the whole of my group thought that while the place is adequate in terms of style and abience, it has little to recommend it from a food or service p.o.v. would not make the same mistake twice.
Less

I'm sorry -- I just don't get the glowing reviews here. It's not that the food was bad -- it's just that some of it was mediocre at best. As far as the atmosphere -- nice for the person facing into... More

I'm sorry -- I just don't get the glowing reviews here. It's not that the food was bad -- it's just that some of it was mediocre at best. As far as the atmosphere -- nice for the person facing into the restuarant, but really bad for the person facing the unattractive wall. Dinner came to over $70 -- not bad for a great meal -- but this just didn't hit the mark. Appetizer (rabbit) was good, but main course (trout) was dried out and tasteless. Dessert (sundae) was completely average. However, the service was very nice and attentive. Pros: good service Cons: overpriced, mediocre food
Less

Every time I go to Red Cat, I enjoy myself, but this said, the food quality has dropped a bit in the last year (otherwise, I would have given it another star). The apps are great and I recommend... More

Every time I go to Red Cat, I enjoy myself, but this said, the food quality has dropped a bit in the last year (otherwise, I would have given it another star). The apps are great and I recommend sticking with them .. they have good assortment which will fill you up, and you should save room for their desserts which are extraordinary!
Less

This is one of my favorite places for a nice dinner, but the service can be excellent or spotty depending on the night and server. The food is wonderful. Prices are on the high end, but it is... More

This is one of my favorite places for a nice dinner, but the service can be excellent or spotty depending on the night and server. The food is wonderful. Prices are on the high end, but it is usually worth it. PROS: Good food, nice atmosphere CONS: Spotty service
Less

Red Cat is an experience that anyone, whether you're a foodie or not, should experience at some point. Quaint decor, fantastic staff (that bent over backwards for us), delicious cocktails and of... More

Red Cat is an experience that anyone, whether you're a foodie or not, should experience at some point. Quaint decor, fantastic staff (that bent over backwards for us), delicious cocktails and of course, the food, all contribute to a fantastic dining experience. I highly recommend the lobster perogies as a starter, as well as the pork tenderloin entree. Their champagne cocktails are also quite wonderful. If I had to sum up this place: it's ideal for a special night out. Noise levels are not low, but the atmosphere is buzzing with an energy and spirit that will make you want to stick around for a little while and soak it up. Pros: staff, menu, atmosphere
Less

Met a friend for dinner last night and was pleasantly suprized with EVERYTHING that we ordered. The appitizers, entrees, sides and desserts where all phenomenal. The waitress and staff where... More

Met a friend for dinner last night and was pleasantly suprized with EVERYTHING that we ordered. The appitizers, entrees, sides and desserts where all phenomenal. The waitress and staff where knowledgable, friendly and effiecient. There is nothing better than a fabulous dining experience. would recommend!! Pros: great service, excellant selection, quaint decor Cons: ???
Less

The Red Cat is a great neighborhood place. The atmosphere is very nice, but not stuffy. The service has always been excellent. The menu doesn't change all that often, but the food is excellent. ... More

The Red Cat is a great neighborhood place. The atmosphere is very nice, but not stuffy. The service has always been excellent. The menu doesn't change all that often, but the food is excellent. A good range of dishes from seafood like skate and salmon to steak and pork tenderloin. They also have a great wine selection and a nice bar to eat or drink at. Pros: Food, Service, Ambiance
Less

Just moved to NY and have been hopping around areas and eating out lots - this place is definately my fav so far. Great neighbourhood place, excellent food, great service and attention to details as... More

Just moved to NY and have been hopping around areas and eating out lots - this place is definately my fav so far. Great neighbourhood place, excellent food, great service and attention to details as well as knowledge of wine. Low key yet impressive atmosphere - all in all a great package. I live close by adn will definately be back on aregular basis. Pros: Everything!
Less

The restaurant was amazing. It was casual with a great ambience. Everything we ordered was wonderful. Our group had the pork chop, steak and duck. The wine list was wonderful. The location is... More

The restaurant was amazing. It was casual with a great ambience. Everything we ordered was wonderful. Our group had the pork chop, steak and duck. The wine list was wonderful. The location is hard to get to but I will be back when I am in NY again.
Less

Our waitress was rather unattentive. She also seemed a bit annoyed when we asked for a few minutes when we first sat down before actually ordering. However, the wine she picked for us and the food... More

Our waitress was rather unattentive. She also seemed a bit annoyed when we asked for a few minutes when we first sat down before actually ordering. However, the wine she picked for us and the food we ordered certainly made up for this initial annoyance. I had the wild striped bass and it was cooked to perfection. The skin remained crisp, while the meat maintained its succulence. Excellent! Pros: food, crowd Cons: very tight bar area
Less